Elements Mafia 77 - by Linkcat

[rob77dp]

And from my pov, kae is lying scum or another dead town (in essence) threw\screwed the game... 

[skyironsword]

I think we should be ok to lynch the one you say is certainly scum, no? Or is kae scum with you? MW come vote kae ?

Has kae said why he would rb Poke there??

Sorry, I should have been more clear. I wouldn't lynch kae if not for the whole Poke thing. We're free to lynch kae tomorrow, or we can have MW vig kae tonight.

[worldwideweb3]

surely the hesitancy to move from me to someone who a conf town (i hope) is on, is indicative that im a town. Or is the mafia team me and rob now suddenly?

I think that makes as lot of sense.

www3, I read your started reasoning for not protecting Oa... But his role he basically COULDN'T be left alive as town so high likelihood scum were prepared to nk him twice to work around the doc but could have saved him the once?

It was only a 1v1 situation with Oa and mafia that would be bad for mafia and that seemed very unlikely. After todays lynch it would have been 2v2 and game over most likely. I thought mafia would gamble on a you kill because they wouldve expected me to doc Oa after that MW post. I probably should have doc'd Oa but then if they targetted you and killed you, the rest would have said why I didnt protect you, a conf town and I wouldve been lynched for that so 

[skyironsword]

As a side note, if w3 is mafia, we need to lynch him today in case No Cheating can be used to vig one of the living townies. Do not switch to kae.

I have no proof of this, but if rob is a valid target for No Cheating, that would also explain why mafia left him alive.

[worldwideweb3]

You know that no cheating only works through date, and if my target doesnt target anyone else, I cant exactly vig anyone.

Anyways all that doesnt apply because im a townie

[skyironsword]

You know that no cheating only works through date, and if my target doesnt target anyone else, I cant exactly vig anyone.

Anyways all that doesnt apply because im a townie

I suggest you read the rules again:

No Cheating (1U) - If you learned of any targeting during a Date on a previous Night Phase, target one of the involved players. Your target dies.

It is very possible that you saw someone targeting a living town member (possibly rob?) on a previous night.

[worldwideweb3]

I already revealed my targets and what I found, are you suggesting I lied about my targets and that the dead havent come out to say that the info I gave regarding their targets was wrong?

[worldwideweb3]

Also rob will probably know if he has been targetted or not by the dead people. Also, If I had the kill on rob, I wouldve killed him last night and it would be game over. You literally used that logic to rule out MW/Oa/poke teams but you want to lynch me for same reason. Make it make sense?

[skyironsword]

Also rob will probably know if he has been targetted or not by the dead people. Also, If I had the kill on rob, I wouldve killed him last night and it would be game over. You literally used that logic to rule out MW/Oa/poke teams but you want to lynch me for same reason. Make it make sense?

You could not have killed him last night, because I prevented you from doing so.

[worldwideweb3]

Also rob will probably know if he has been targetted or not by the dead people. Also, If I had the kill on rob, I wouldve killed him last night and it would be game over. You literally used that logic to rule out MW/Oa/poke teams but you want to lynch me for same reason. Make it make sense?

You could not have killed him last night, because I prevented you from doing so.

You know I couldve used nurse touch on myself to restore my ability allowing me to carrying out the kill anyways?

Regardless, its not a point worth discussing as im unable to kill rob because no dates found on him plus im a town.

Also I would be more inclined to lynch sky over kae in small scenario that MW is mafia because im more sure that sky is mafia than kae (100% to 95%).

Noob, you really need to move your vote if youre town.

[skyironsword]

Look, your defense is pretty good, but there just isn't anyone else who could realistically be mafia at this point.

[worldwideweb3]

Look, your defense is pretty good, but there just isn't anyone else who could realistically be mafia at this point.

except you....who have done nothing this game except push vig kills on townies.