Elements Mafia 77 - by Linkcat

[skyironsword]

There are three scenarios here:

1. You are mafia.
2. serprex failed to inform us that he decided to roleblock you.
3. kae is mafia and lied about not roleblocking you.

Of those three scenarios, the first is the most likely. If you flip town, we can reevaluate. That doesn't make your lynch any less reasonable.

[Pokechu]

Like do y’all not realize how bad that sounds… “we’re lynching him because he says he got blocked”

Damn… do y’all not have any substance to add to that?? Like why lynch someone because they got blocked… not like they would choose to get blocked LOL like that is such a poor reason to vote

the longer you go though poke on that line of statements, the more it starts to feel like Right But For The Wrong Reasons kind of defense....?

I feel like this is you saying, the longer I talk about scum!Gura it feels like you guys are right for lynching me but for the wrong reasons

If you are, then that’s dumb LOL and you shouldn’t be the one to say that because you’re speaking from a position of privilege as a mechanically confirmed town player. I’m not even beating a dead horse w scum!gura, it’s not exasperated. it’s genuine analysis and observations about the motives scum!Gura would have needed to kill serp. How are you going to say that trying to solve and deduce motivations (which, you’re supposed to do in mafia to determine whether someone best fits as town or scum) is coming off as “we’re right but for the wrong reasons”

[Pokechu]

There are three scenarios here:

1. You are mafia.
2. serprex failed to inform us that he decided to roleblock you.
3. kae is mafia and lied about not roleblocking you.

Of those three scenarios, the first is the most likely. If you flip town, we can reevaluate. That doesn't make your lynch any less reasonable.

It does make it less reasonable, it absolutely does because it shows that you’re only basing your vote off mechanics. This is not the first time any of you have seen a framed town player so IDK why you’re acting like it is LOL it’s a shallow move to just vote out the town player (and say their whole defense “doesn’t make sense”) instead of trying to systemically analyze the likeliest scenario

[kaempfer13]

www3 (3) - Rob, Oa, kaempfer13
Poke (3) - MasterNoob, www3, skyironsword
Sky (1) - Pokechu

Giving rob the time he needs to explain his last thought.

[Pokechu]

Are you implying that serprex roleblocked you and decided not to mention it to rob?

makes more sense than the alternative. serprex literally rambled about KDZ being his top scumread when KDZ was already dead, so yeah.

also maybe kae blocked me and is just lying. All I know is I got blocked.

Also answered point 2 here

GG with the “no-brainer” move

[skyironsword]

There are three scenarios here:

1. You are mafia.
2. serprex failed to inform us that he decided to roleblock you.
3. kae is mafia and lied about not roleblocking you.

Of those three scenarios, the first is the most likely. If you flip town, we can reevaluate. That doesn't make your lynch any less reasonable.

It does make it less reasonable, it absolutely does because it shows that you’re only basing your vote off mechanics. This is not the first time any of you have seen a framed town player so IDK why you’re acting like it is LOL it’s a shallow move to just vote out the town player (and say their whole defense “doesn’t make sense”) instead of trying to systemically analyze the likeliest scenario

We know you can be town. But if you're town, assuming serprex isn't stupid, kae is mafia. We'll find a mafia member if we lynch both of you, and you're more likely to be mafia, so we're starting with you. I won't explain this again.

[rob77dp]

Poke-
Is your stance "why would Poke!gura Trident target serp same night as scum nk's serp" ?

[Pokechu]

There are three scenarios here:

1. You are mafia.
2. serprex failed to inform us that he decided to roleblock you.
3. kae is mafia and lied about not roleblocking you.

Of those three scenarios, the first is the most likely. If you flip town, we can reevaluate. That doesn't make your lynch any less reasonable.

It does make it less reasonable, it absolutely does because it shows that you’re only basing your vote off mechanics. This is not the first time any of you have seen a framed town player so IDK why you’re acting like it is LOL it’s a shallow move to just vote out the town player (and say their whole defense “doesn’t make sense”) instead of trying to systemically analyze the likeliest scenario

We know you can be town. But if you're town, assuming serprex isn't stupid, kae is mafia. We'll find a mafia member if we lynch both of you, and you're more likely to be mafia, so we're starting with you. I won't explain this again.

You don’t have to explain, it doesn’t make sense regardless. Hooray for scum!Gura not using Trident!!! Def believable :^)

[skyironsword]

www3 (4) - Rob, Oa, kaempfer13, skyironsword
Poke (2) - MasterNoob, www3
Sky (1) - Pokechu

Stalling for time, but I intend to put my vote back before the day ends. Kae, rob, please move your votes back to Poke.

[Pokechu]

Poke-
Is your stance "why would Poke!gura Trident target serp same night as scum nk's serp" ?

No. It’s not

It’s everything. Why would scum!Gura choose to kill serp when it implicates him the most out of all the players

And also refuse to use Trident on Oa when the thread was saying for Trident to be used (because scum!Gura holstering just means mafia misses out on a free kill)

And also who would scum!Gura bloop then? Presumably KDZ. But we know KDZ wasn’t blooped because Oa’s kill on them worked, if KDZ was blooped then W3’s kill would’ve worked.

[kaempfer13]

www3 (3) - Rob, Oa, skyironsword
Poke (3) - MasterNoob, www3, kaempfer13
Sky (1) - Pokechu

Rob was never on poke, rob very much wants the w3 lynch. Also, he should be busy typing.

[skyironsword]

www3 (2) - Rob, Oa
Poke (4) - MasterNoob, www3, kaempfer13, skyironsword
Sky (1) - Pokechu

Poor choice of words, I suppose. I just meant "move your vote to Poke" in general.