Elements Mafia 76 - by serprex

[andretimpa]

They only know the ability failed then? Same thing as if the tatget was immaterial?

[serprex]

Yes

[TheonlyrealBeef]

I don't know if anyone's mentioned yet that Oa's vote on mathman broke a tie and then wasn't removed for the rest of the day. He also mentioned that he wanted one train to gain traction rather than vote juggle at eod. Could this have been pointing to a lucky N0 FG glimpse?

I cannot say for certain that is false, but as a fellow European, I think he simply wanted to break a tie and settle whom to lynch before going to sleep afterwards.

[TheonlyrealBeef]

Although there is no guarantee that there is a GA, finding out people have "useless" roles and revealing them does increase the odds of mafia finding GA if they exist.
When all the useless roles are revealed, all that remains must be something worth keeping secret, after all.

Distribution of roles not being explicitly random likely has to do with maintaining balance, despite anything being possible with randomness. So town having 1 GA is plausible, 2 GA is unlikely, while 3 GA would almost certainly cause mod override.

There is something I am looking for in reads lists, but it won't do to point it out unless I get most peoples' read lists. So I would love more of those and elaborate something town should be looking into.

[iancudorinmarian]

andretimpa (2)- Linkcat, MasterNoob
worldwideweb3 (2) - TheonlyrealBeef, iancudorinmarian

The dice have spoken.

[worldwideweb3]

n- : root, TorB, link (mainly cause all of them are still alive lol), math (Oa in Him, his train disappeared v fast), ian (talk about low content posts…)
n: andre, naii
n+: MW, annele,

andretimpa (2)- Linkcat, MasterNoob
worldwideweb3 (2) - TheonlyrealBeef, iancudorinmarian
Mathman101 (1) - worldwideweb3

[andretimpa]

Looking at my n- list we have w3, ian, Annele and math.

• My main problem with w3 is that he's mostly posting low content stuff (tho he just posted reads, so that will hopefully change later).
• My problem with ian and Annele is they are mostly afk
• For math, on top of being really afk I keep coming back to the timing of his last vote in EOD. From my readlist:
  

  (n-) mathman101 - Has been afk through most of D1. But I'd like to call attention to the timing of his final vote. It seems it was being typed at the same time as mine (specially if you consider it being on mobile), so he was also going for a hammer here. My motivation for hammering shock was avoiding a No Lynch which was imminent and would have made EOD1 a larger fiasco than it was. I hope his motivation was similar.
  

So I'd say math is the most solid of those reads

andretimpa (2)- Linkcat, MasterNoob
worldwideweb3 (2) - TheonlyrealBeef, iancudorinmarian
Mathman101 (2) - worldwideweb3, andretimpa

I'm not opposed to move to w3, but keeping the trains tied seems OK for now and w3 is starting to show potential.

[Linkcat]

That's more like it, today could be interesting. Hopefully I wake up before deadline this time.

[Naii_the_Baf]

Since everyone else is doing one I might as well make one myself.

Spoiler for Reads:

n+
MasterWalks: Actively attemping to engage in meaningful discussion imo, and nothing really looks out of place from him.

n
Linkcat: I like to think Link is a book no one knows the language for.

TheonlyrealBeef: Null read.

n-
worldwideweb3: His D1 vote has me an eyebrow raised, as he could very easily have tied wagons by voting shock (and he was one of the wagons as well) when he voted and instead chose to vote me. w3, do you have any reason to suspect me? I'm not entirely certain that's a random vote, even if it wasn't me being voted. He also did argue that he was following TorB's suggestion, even if said suggestion wasn't for voting, if that amounts to something.

andretimpa: Nothing that hasn't been said before, just voting shock back after pushing him to reveal info and threatening to vote him if he didn't. In the end it was an empty threat and shock should have never revealed his info.

Not voting yet, I'd like to have w3 answer my question. Otherwise my vote's on w3.

[worldwideweb3]

Since everyone else is doing one I might as well make one myself.

Spoiler for Reads:

n+
MasterWalks: Actively attemping to engage in meaningful discussion imo, and nothing really looks out of place from him.

n
Linkcat: I like to think Link is a book no one knows the language for.

TheonlyrealBeef: Null read.

n-
worldwideweb3: His D1 vote has me an eyebrow raised, as he could very easily have tied wagons by voting shock (and he was one of the wagons as well) when he voted and instead chose to vote me. w3, do you have any reason to suspect me? I'm not entirely certain that's a random vote, even if it wasn't me being voted. He also did argue that he was following TorB's suggestion, even if said suggestion wasn't for voting, if that amounts to something.

andretimpa: Nothing that hasn't been said before, just voting shock back after pushing him to reveal info and threatening to vote him if he didn't. In the end it was an empty threat and shock should have never revealed his info.

Not voting yet, I'd like to have w3 answer my question. Otherwise my vote's on w3.

It was a completely random vote. It’s better to have multiple wagons than just a couple, esp day 1 when there’s not much info anyways. I tend not to vote for counter wagon just to save myself, only if I acc feel they’re mafia. I remember trying to save shock in a previous mafia cause I didn’t read him as mafia, even tho he was the only other big wagon. A mafia me wouldve just piled on shock lol instead of voting you

[Linkcat]

I actually do remember that, but I think you would be consistent across alignments. NAI for me.

Full reads list will have to wait until Night, I'm way too tired and my power may go out again at any time. It's not even storming...

I'm cool with a lynch on andre or a bottom half poster.

[worldwideweb3]

Can the links to each phase post be added to OP/the post with rules please