Elements Mafia 75 - by rob77dp

[Naii_the_Baf]

No explanation = no real read.

v
andre: Put on immaterial; really don't think scum would make other scum immaterial. Self immaterial could maybe make sense as scum, but Cal has been online and didn't refute the Psion check.

n+
Nae: Don't really think she's scum, not entirely sure she's town either. Alibi for Anubis checks out, so n+.
MW/Coffee: Role interaction.

n
Oa: Besides the moe Deja partner thing (which I don't really find leaning any way), nothing has really stood out to me.
Cal

n-
kae: Amber Nymph usage; do you have a reason for giving andre─ or anyone for that matter─ momentum, or was there some post I'm not aware of justifying this?
shock: Few posts, but besides the targeting ones (which could very well be crumbs for later use), I don't find him scummy tbh. Didn't actually say his target N1 and claimed D2 to have targeted andre.

w
kdz: Lynched ian with a very flimsy excuse (although it could also be not wanting to extend the game too much), doesn't really have anything going for him regarding the Anubis topic.

[killsdazombies]

He was just a low poster, much like yourself, that had a vote, and it would break a tie. Call it what you want, but its not like anyone else is stepping up to bat this game, plus I've been actively trying to encourage people to talk more. I was already in the towns good graces for the most part, so I felt comfortable enforcing an essentially random execution. Besides, why would a mafia make a move at all? When the town is inactive, there is very little reason for a mafia to promote, and demonstrate activity. Easier to hide in a silent crowd then speak out from it.

Frankly, everyone who voted yesterday has a + bump in my book for actually participating, and everyone who didn't has a mark against them.

[Naii_the_Baf]

shock: Few posts, but besides the targeting ones (which could very well be crumbs for later use), I don't find him scummy tbh. Didn't actually say his target N1 and claimed D2 to have targeted andre, so n-.

EBWOP just in case. I'm kind of contradicting myself without noting this.

[andretimpa]

@Naii

tbh I would have switched from Cal if the vote remained tied. I also remember you being around EOD (at the time there was a single vote from kae on ian). If you thought our reasons for lynching ian were flimsy you should have at least spoken up.

[andretimpa]

I'm targeting coffee tonight.

I’m targetting shockcannon tonight.

I'm not targetting anyone tonight

Also, to encourage more posts, remember that crumbing can be useful later on in the game.

[andretimpa]

A quick update to my reads, in case I croak (might have been the reason for the Anubis after all)

v

Spoiler for MasterWalks:

I'm not noticing anything out of the ordinary on his play, which is telling since iirc we haven't seen scum!MW. I'd expect at least some change in his gameplay. His damselfly interaction with Coffee seems very genuine.

Spoiler for kdz:

Considering everything I have gathered, I'm fairly confident that kdz is town. You guys should listen to him and start to actually play the game.

n+

Spoiler for shockcannon:

The main factors at play so far are his interactions with serp (see my previous read). D2 interactions seemed townie to me. I'd recommend shock doesn't push his secrecy too much, if you can share an information, sharing will likely help town.

Spoiler for Coffeeditto:

He is above n mostly due to his interactions with MW. He is not at v, because his scumstyle is still fresh in my memory and I see some similarities (might just be he always plays like this).

Spoiler for Naesala:

Her confusion seems genuine, not faked. I think it would be safe to get her lynched at some later point due to her being uncheckable, but we have some people more likely to be scum in the mean time.

Spoiler for kaempfer13:

Is actually trying to participate, which is more than a lot of us (just keep the double/triple posts in check, this is not a competition for the highest post count ).

n

Spoiler for PlayerOa:

Someone more cynical than me would likely say that Oa's claim of being deja with the guy that disappeared, plus the timing of it is convenient. The only scenario where he was the Anubis is if he claimed to be Anubis in n0 due to rolling it in n1 (thus setting his alibi early on). I'm not placing him lower because comboing that with a deja claim is very risky (I can see much easier ways to implement this alibi as scum).

n-

Spoiler for Calindu:

This might be tunneling on my part. I'm willing to go for a different lynch today.

Spoiler for Naii_the_Baf:

Could very well be lying about not having used Anubis. His reads are fairly missaligned with mine too, which raises me an eyebrow.

[rob77dp]

Night 2 has concluded - hold please while the bits and bytes are compiled, analyzed, and tabulated. The results will be posted soon^(TM)...

Please hold until further notice...

[rob77dp]

DAY 3

MasterWalks was nightkilled. He was an Elemental and a Fate Egg. [Otyugh]

DAY 3 has concluded.

[rob77dp]

Start of Day 3, hatching reports (for Day 3 through Night 3) are submitted, refer to nearest Inbox location for your new ability assignments.

Spoiler for LIVING PLAYERS:

3. PlayerOa
4. Coffeeditto
6. Naesala
8. shockcannon
10. kaempfer13
11. killsdazombies
14. Naii_the_Baf
15. andretimpa
16. Calindu

[killsdazombies]

That feels like a strange kill

[Naii_the_Baf]

That feels like a strange kill

It was probably because pretty much everyone townread him, but I agree with the sentiment.

[andretimpa]

@shock/coffee did anything interesting came out from targetting each other?