My thoughts on what happened:
Cecilia killing dawn was a bad play imo. I'd be okay with it had dawn remained completely silent or had just made a single post to avoid a modkill. Instead he started being more active in N1. imo the better play would have been to target Cal to put some pressure on him to participate a bit more. Also, with the amount of people wanting to lynch Cecilia right now, I doubt even a town!Cecilia would step forward.
Town!Cecilla has to come forward now and explain, otherwise the more time it passes, the scummier it looks. At least if it happens now, it can be discussed and we can reach a conclusion about it, but otherwise Cecilla wouldn't be able to use their role anymore without being outed on the spot and probably lynched.
I am not convinced town needs to know Cecilia's identity any more. As soon as she targets a not commonly scumread person, she should get outed, though. Also, apparently my idea's for Cecilia don't matter too much to Cecilia. So, if we collectively allow Cecilia to vig scummy people there will be plenty scummy townsfolk that a potential mafia could get rid of. I do not like this. I also would want her outed if she makes that attempt.
I would ideally like the next votes to be from kdz/moe/cal/naii before the usual actives start talking/voting etc
You're not an all too unlikely candidate yourself. But I am not so well at scumreading people.
moe ─ I didn't bother to read much into him after some of those damn big posts, but I agree with most of the statements in what I did read.
That's not good, this is where I post my thoughts on ten pages of content. The small posts only reflect a fraction of that.
N-
Rob: Been vocal about this already. Gut feeling about Link NK but i didnt want to list him in the everyone else catagory.
You cannot deduct mafia form the NK target. There are information roles and some people are good at solving and pose a greater risk as town. rob is not the only one to know this.
N--
Coffee: REALLY dont like the promise to protect then failing to do so. Almost feels like you said you would so that he didnt get targeted by anything else as to not disrupt the kill. Like roleswapping or not, thats kinda scummy thing to do. Also, id like to point out him telling info roles to not reveal anything. There are only 3 mafia this game. A mafia kill now would set us FAR ahead. Info roles could be killed off before sharing as we are already 3 town down.
I don't think anyone pegged Coffee as Fu Hua after his post. You cannot announce to mafia what the power roles are going to do exactly. Your point baffles me. I don't like the term 'roleswapping' it's just a fancy word for a concept that's always been there. Of course you're going to muddy the water for yourself and mafia information acquisition!?
To be fair, I guess I try to be a bit harsher than usual as there's a bit of OMGUS going on on my part.
While thinking it over, I have this strange feeling that Cecilia is indeed mafia, with both them and at least one mafia buddy trying to completely ignore this discussion point, despite a lot of people having given their opinion about this. Trying to give your opinion about it after this post would be moot, of course, nor do I have any substantial evidence. Just a gut feeling enhanced by the fact that the mafia team I currently have in my head is staying awfully silent about Cecilia. Which would make my n- reads MW and w3 town.
I also look at them with suspicion and like your this post in general as it gives me some direction towards solving. I am far from getting scumreads but looking at your play it shows a distinct path to follow.
People I am currently fine placing my vote on: MW, w3, ian, Naii out of the more suspicious looking lot. Cal, DC, andre, kdz I still don't have a read. Sub I don't think I will ever get one.
iancudorinmarian (3) - TheonlyrealBeef, andretimpa, killsdazombies
DoubleCapitals (1) - rob77dp
rob77dp (1) - MasterWalks
worldwideweb3 (2) - iancudorinmarian, Naii_the_Baf
Naii_the_Baf (1) - PlayerOa
killsdazombies (1) - worldwideweb3
MasterWalks (3) - Calindu, DoubleCapitals, moehrpi
I did not expect to be stuck with the same reads I had D1.
Poll
