Elements Mafia 74 - by skyironsword

[Submachine]

I am more concerned about all the hard not Durandal claims, though. The pool of possible cops is rapidly shrinking at this pace.

If the cop is smart, he already soft/hard-claimed not-Durandal.

[worldwideweb3]

Www is suspiciously overplaying the towny confusion in this game. (3 weird attempts already) He might be mafia trying to look town.

your question was a  What question tho. Why would you say "to the players", its better to ask host. Secondly, youre one of the people who is acc usually very thorough and has read rules and roles like multiple times. Thirdly, we've already been talking about rita, so you know that exists. Fourthly, do you really expect mafia to be able to use other players' role freely? Fifthly, atleast i replied to it and carrying on the conversation, while Oa and kaemp just ignored it (possibly because of the nature of the What question tho)

[kaempfer13]

Role question to the players:

Can Mafia use other players' roles? Roles that they do not have.

only way to plan copying a role is to lynch someone with a certain role while being sin mal. rita can redirect the targeting to self (as torb said not smart). the honkai cores all give or deny info or poison.
only way to duplicate a living role is by being seele.
Obviously some honkai core holders may try to disguise themselves as other roles, but its possible to catch them redhanded.

[kaempfer13]

oops forgot raiden redirecting

[TheonlyrealBeef]

I am more concerned about all the hard not Durandal claims, though. The pool of possible cops is rapidly shrinking at this pace.

If the cop is smart, he already soft/hard-claimed not-Durandal.

After establishing a no lying policy, this would be pretty risky. The only role Durandal can safely pretend as is Emma Planck (knows Durandal identity if my plan was followed and has the same ability type), which would still be a priority NK target.

[kaempfer13]

Also yh, sub of all people not reading the rules is actually really weird. Seems like this is another one of his roleplays. Does he do that all the time (figuring a new playstyle each game) regardless of alignement or only when he doesnt read his role or is scum?

[Submachine]

@Kae, www:

I am still a bit exhausted from the previous mafia, so I need a change of pace this time.

I already showed I can play the high effort game as mafia, so now it's time to test out the low effort game as town.

[kaempfer13]

Hm, still I had the impression that rulebending is your favourite thing to do, so i would have expected your low effort game to consist of not adressing the thread that much and make crazy mechanical plans. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Also, I'm a little weirded out that you are that agressive when you clearly didnt put in the effort to achieve any lvl of confidence.

Oh well, i suppose non of those things is AI, just means that my ability to predict how people behave is lackluster.

[Submachine]

I mostly plan to just follow my gut this game. That would explain the thing you are weirded out by.

I don't intend to spend hours doing stuff, but I will still solve.

Www is suspiciously overplaying the towny confusion in this game. (3 weird attempts already) He might be mafia trying to look town.

your question was a  What question tho. Why would you say "to the players", its better to ask host. Secondly, youre one of the people who is acc usually very thorough and has read rules and roles like multiple times. Thirdly, we've already been talking about rita, so you know that exists. Fourthly, do you really expect mafia to be able to use other players' role freely? Fifthly, atleast i replied to it and carrying on the conversation, while Oa and kaemp just ignored it (possibly because of the nature of the What question tho)

Scummy response for a few reasons.

- Does not address him being called out as scummy.
- Goes defensive by trying to discredit me.
- Putting words in my mouth. ("you know that exists")
- Pretending to be useful while not. ("atleast i replied to it and carrying on the conversation")

[kaempfer13]

so you got me curious about coffe rob and the only game in the last 35 where he has over 20 posts was mafia 68.

Where he was -drumroll-

Spoiler for Hidden:

town

[worldwideweb3]

I mostly plan to just follow my gut this game. That would explain the thing you are weirded out by.

I don't intend to spend hours doing stuff, but I will still solve.

Www is suspiciously overplaying the towny confusion in this game. (3 weird attempts already) He might be mafia trying to look town.

your question was a  What question tho. Why would you say "to the players", its better to ask host. Secondly, youre one of the people who is acc usually very thorough and has read rules and roles like multiple times. Thirdly, we've already been talking about rita, so you know that exists. Fourthly, do you really expect mafia to be able to use other players' role freely? Fifthly, atleast i replied to it and carrying on the conversation, while Oa and kaemp just ignored it (possibly because of the nature of the What question tho)

Scummy response for a few reasons.

- Does not address him being called out as scummy.
- Goes defensive by trying to discredit me.
- Putting words in my mouth. ("you know that exists")
- Pretending to be useful while not. ("atleast i replied to it and carrying on the conversation")

[iancudorinmarian]

dawn to dusk (3) - TheonlyrealBeef, rob77dp, Naii_the_Baf
moehrpi (1) - kaempfer13
shockcannon (2) - Linkcat, iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (1) - worldwideweb3
worldwideweb3 (1) - DoubleCapitals
kaempfer13 (1) - MasterWalks

I agree with Link, why is shock still alive? We don't need some rogue town or annoying mafia running around.

No-lynch is bad. Anyone who claims no-lynch is a viable strategy is either bad or trolling.

Also, kae is either high or scum. Or both.