Spoiler for Hidden:
Heres a question then. Do we believe Rob/shock are different alignments? If so, we have two pretty good options/outcomes
If shock is innocent, and we conclude rob in mafia, annele can eat rob. Should that fail, we can lynch rob ourselves. (Either because Annele gets nightkilled or rob gets protected somehow)
If rob is innocent, we don't really have an offensive cover, shock will almost certainly survive the night given how tied he is with annele.
I'm inclined to believe shock, I would rather lynch rob over shock, but it might be safer to hedge our bet.
This of course dismisses my earlier tinfoil, that neither are mafia, but I dont know if thats even possible tbh.
I'd like to hear thoughts on this, specifically from MW, who is the only Conf town in my book, Shock, who I believe more then rob, and Sub, who while I believe shock, still seems town to me.
And obvious annele if they log in.
[1]
im down to lynch rob.
If Rob flips town we lynch shock.
If shock flips town and we lose.
Ill believe shock due to no one else has a better plan.
What? lynch annele? if annele flips mafia then yay we got the inactive one and cue ridiculously paranoid vote pattern readings.
If she flips town, then we probably lynch rob see [1]
I say we skip the annele step, lynch rob and hope for mafia flip. (inb4 annele flip maf and people use this against me)
Im confirmed town on pretty much everyones radar. I will most likely be NK'd next. Probably wont be able to get another ability use. I say if town FE rolls dragonfly, target andre.
Annele, if your town and rob flips town, eat shock. dont let him spew anymore nonsense.
My scum reads so far
V
MasterWalks
jcj
n+
n-
W
Everyone else
Ge0metry v1.2 (1) - kaempfer13
rob77dp (2) - shockcannon, MasterWalks
I was saying Shock has locked themselves in with annele, I'm willing to bet both either share an alignment or shock thinks they do, I wasn't suggesting an annele lynch, just that annele could eat someone as long as they aren't nightkilled or blocked.
If rob flips town though, its likely annele flips mafia with shock imo. or at least, its a spooky territory.
Math time
Worst case scenario for a rob flip town and annele is mafia
If we flip Rob, and they are town we go from 3 v 7 to 3 v 6. Then NK, putting us at 3v5, then annele eats a town. 3v4, and shock actually is fate egg manages to roll otyugh/Splatoon OR n2 shock rolled toadfish and poisoned someone, thus theyll die tonight leaving us 3v3.
Worst case we flip shock and shock is town
Similar pattern, NK puts us at 3v5. Annele should be pretty okay, they eat rob, and assuming shock and rob are V/W it goes to 2v5. If they aren't its 3v4 and were at a similar scenario for the above.
All lines of play I can see right now revolve around managing the risk annele innately presents by being otyugh.