I did not have the time to in-depth analyze the posts between the last post in my Wall Part 2 and today, so I will mostly rely on my memory for this.
1. iancudorinmarian: I used to have him at n- because of subtle, scummy things, but during EOD1, he came online and people told him to quickly place his vote, and he voted on serprex (one of the Deja Vu claims). This kind of joke/confusion would be bad for Mafia; they would not risk the negative attention this brings, or he would know better from his teammates. Now at n+.
2. TheonlyrealBeef: He is consistent with his mindset (he held true to his argument against N0 Otyugh throughout) and he also solves fairly often. He is one of the few people who read and react my walls, which is a plus. He leans v.
4. Annele: She made a few early comments that some people liked, but other than being logical, I found her arguments neutral. It looked like her wagon was the most vulnerable to an unorchestrated lynch, which implies she had no teammates to save her. Not enough to go on, so pure n.
5. kaempfer13: He seemed confused on multiple occasions; questioning what MW knows about him, rob's sudden vote switch during EOD1, and he also tried to solve. Looks like the usual townie confusion. He also suggested that shock might have him as confirmed town, but shock has yet to confirm it. He collected quite a number of bad attention to himself, but unless shock denies his credibility about the Fate GN thing, I give him the benefit of the doubt and put him in n+.
6. Calindu: Similar to Annele, except the almost dying part. Again, he had early comments that other people liked but I found neutral. Not enough to go on, and others also seem to only suspect him because of POE, so n.
7. Linkcat: He is the most active, attracts the most attention, and leads everyone to do what he thinks they should do. This is the opposite of what a mafia should do, but he is U N R E A D A B L E, so straight to n. He speaks confidently about knowing things, which is the opposite of the townie confusion that would be logical. Maybe he knows that not enough people would question him if he tried to pull this off as mafia. However, he is still a valuable asset in case he is Town, so keeping him alive longer is worth it.
10. serprex: If he was not Deja Vu, I would think he is n-, but he is Deja Vu.
11. MasterWalks: I would have said n- at first, because of some questions I had about him, but I get it now. The way he makes his plays, he's like a mirror of myself from my early days. Without revealing why, I think he leans v. I am very much looking forward to why he wanted my readlist so badly.
12. andretimpa: He was the leading train for the longest time during Day 1, yet barely anyone seemed to care to save him. Though I'm not sure if that's true, because a lot of O R C H E S T R A T I O N went down at EOD1, which eventually kept him alive. I only briefly saw he made a longer post today, but I did not have the time to process it yet, so n-.
13. rob77dp: He does the combination of planning, solving, and making mistakes/bad calls, all that scream town to me. His confusion about Linkcat during EOD1 seemed genuine, even if it was warranted. However, I am still cautious about him for past reasons. v for now.
14. shockcannon: I am one of the few people who care about what shock says, except when he tries to lynch one of the two people who I don't want to see lynched yet. He has his "bloc" with people who trust him, including Dejaprex. If I understood correctly, he makes plans for Town, but he also has the anti-town feat of seemingly knowing too much too early. His bravado explains the latter part, so he's n+ in my book.
15. killsdazombies: I dunno. n.
16. DoubleCapitals: Same as kdz, except he did the same thing once as scum!d2d did in the previous mafia: use an out-of-context snippet of a conversation and use it to attempt discrediting someone. Not too much to go on, but n-.
18. Ge0metry v1.2: His few posts don't stick out to me, other than relatively new to our current meta. Though as I remember, he joined by saying he played mafia before, but until I look at a past mafia where he played, he's n to me. (Fun fact: I wanted to target him before I looked at my role.)
And if I organize it, it looks as follows:
(Confirmed: serprex)
| v | - TheonlyrealBeef
- MasterWalks
- rob77dp
|
| n+ | - iancudorinmarian
- kaempfer13
- shockcannon
|
| n | - Annele
- Calindu
- Linkcat
- killsdazombies
- Ge0metry v1.2
|
| n- | |
| w | |
@MW: The ball is now in your court.
Poll
