also the friendly neighbor strategy shock is suggesting works with literally anyone and i somewhat doubt its worth it even under normal circumstances (just plain have whoever friendly neighbor talked to give a list of names the neighbor is among and let the officer identify them, but waste tons of actions and how exactly does the officer even contact the friendly neighbor without revealing?). i assume shocks galaxy brain stuff isnt worth our time, so if you have nothing better to do I will explain my gunsmith strategy in more detail:
since roughly half the roles are unarmed it should cut the community into 2 clean halves. yes, mafia will probably lie here in part, but it doubles the chances of gunsmith finding a suitable target (since armed civilians are wasted time for gunsmith). If its true its an instant confirmed villager for the gunsmith, if its a false claim and town doesnt have complete morons we got a confirmed scum (rather than gunsmith having to distinguish for powerrole vs scum). additionally splitting the community into 2 parts makes it easier to find a townmotivated consensus if we only target 1 half of it at first. It's major drawback of course is that all of gunsmith, officer and graverobber are in the armed half, meaning that both we and mafia are more likely to kill our most important roles.