Elements Mafia 72 - by Ginyu

[Submachine]

@PlayerOa: True. That's why my updated suggestion is for Drug Dealers and Musicians to make noise only once per game, but during any phase. (Quote from my last post: "They both make noise only once during the game (during any phase).")

I post my updated plan below. Now this plan REALLY shouldn't have any downsides.

I think it's a good plan for all Drug Dealers and Musicians to make noise only once during the game, but at any phase. The Officer may or may not use Raid, who knows. This uncertainty keeps the Mafia guessing whether the one-time noisemakers had any Officers in it.

[worldwideweb3]

Shit, I actually forgot that someone was going to die this phase. Doc on me. Don't listen to w3, he's mafia.

Using doc on a mafia is a waste of a role. Don’t use it on link.

[PlayerOa]

I can stand behind that updated plan, Sub.

[Submachine]

 

[worldwideweb3]

Can’t officer just role claim and have the doc protect him every night? (I haven’t looked at rules properly so don’t gang up if I’m missing something )

[iancudorinmarian]

Doctor: Heal (ER): Target any player including yourself. They are protected from the Nightkill and all abilities that would kill. Fails if the target was healed or given Strange Pills the last night.

So no, that can't be done, and it also leads to a boring "follow the cop" game.

[iancudorinmarian]

EBWOP: It would lead

[iancudorinmarian]

And Sub's "plan" is basically "ok officer, do whatever you want". 10/10.

Tbh, this seems to me like Sub is trying to be "helpful" in an attempt to seem civvy.

Seems like I've found a good D1 lynch.

[moehrpi]

@PlayerOa: True. That's why my updated suggestion is for Drug Dealers and Musicians to make noise only once per game, but during any phase. (Quote from my last post: "They both make noise only once during the game (during any phase).")

I post my updated plan below. Now this plan REALLY shouldn't have any downsides.

I think it's a good plan for all Drug Dealers and Musicians to make noise only once during the game, but at any phase. The Officer may or may not use Raid, who knows. This uncertainty keeps the Mafia guessing whether the one-time noisemakers had any Officers in it.

I would not call this a plan either. But the idea is not bad. Just keep noise to a minimum.

[kaempfer13]

Honestly? I sorta like that "plan". I assume people get notified when they lose their abilities and haunt is the only way for that to happen and it creates noise. there is a downside in case mafia has a drug dealer and someone makes noise the same day haunt is used. Another one if drug dealer makes the officer make noise (alternately only target yourself ever, but then we are back to softclaiming)

[kaempfer13]

Basically the "plan" we arrive at at the end is only complain about noise if someone complains about losing abilities.

[moehrpi]

I initially read it that it only makes noise when it fails. Now I expect a lot less haunting than I did before.