Elements Mafia 72 - by Ginyu

[worldwideweb3]

MasterWalks (2) - worldwideweb3, InsignificantWeeaboo
InsignificantWeeaboo (3) - Annele, TheonlyrealBeef, MasterWalks
Calindu (5) - PlayerOa, Linkcat, Submachine, iancudorinmarian, vagman13

[vagman13]

82 friggin pages! Bring chat back!

[Annele]

Slight mafia read on dawn.

Will sort the rest into whoever another time.

This is why I’m struggling to scum read IW.

I dunno, this post was made after a bunch of other people scumread dawn and almost lynched him, and was not followed up by a vote in the next round. In fact, IW proceeded to only vote to protect Mobian. To me reads as an easy scum read to throw off suspicion early on. Did IW ever "sort the rest" in the end?

[kaempfer13]

Yh, requesting full readlist from IW.
I will likely vote for one of cal and IW.

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

Town:
kae
ian
TorB
Sub

Neutral/Unsure: (Top to bottom is Town to Maf)
w3
Annele
vagman
MW
Cali

Maf:
Oa

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

MasterWalks (1) - worldwideweb3
InsignificantWeeaboo (3) - Annele, TheonlyrealBeef, MasterWalks
Calindu (6) - PlayerOa, Linkcat, Submachine, iancudorinmarian, vagman13, InsignificantWeeaboo

[kaempfer13]

Yo, hold up, there is a scumread on a player that requested a gunsmith check there. Not saying it's impossible, but whats your basis?

[kaempfer13]

also where's Link?

[Annele]

@ IW Can I ask for reasonings for your reads? (Edit since kae beat me to it:) Also yeah, where's Link?

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

Link is in Maf.

I might be misremembering things again, but I could've sworn Oa was defending either d2d or mobi at some point. That and I agree with the notation that mafia might be requesting gunsmith checks because either there is no gunsmith or gunsmith is mafia.

[kaempfer13]

You know who else defended Mobi?
I outlined why maf has almost no way of knowing if town has a gunsmith (there is no limit to the role either, so maf having one doesnt mean a thing even if they do) and that the odds are stacked against them.
Also need your reason for Link maf.

And why is ian so high if you dont trust the gunsmith argument?

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Town:
kae
ian
TorB
Sub

Neutral/Unsure: (Top to bottom is Town to Maf)
w3
Annele
vagman
MW
Cali

Maf:
Oa

kae - He's been doing a lot of things that benefit town (making most of the plans, and lynchlogs)
ian - He seems to know what he's doing judging by the whole motion sensor thing he's doing.
TorB - Same reasoning as kae
Sub - I trust that his grid is there for a good reason, even if we don't know what it is right now.
w3 - A little aggressive, but I don't think that means he's maf. Still a bit sus.
Annele - I don't know much about her mafia playstyle, but doesn't seem to be too scummy.
vagman - He's been inactive for a good portion of the game, otherwise don't have too many reads on him
MW - The contradictions from earlier, but I'm also thinking the reason he's playing differently is because of his supposed important role. Still keeping an eye on him.
Cali - A bunch of others have reasons to think he's maf, but I haven't looked too much into him yet.
(Already mentioned Oa)
Link - (Yes, I know I defended Mobi but that was mostly because of his previous mafias.) Actually starting to move him into neutral but probably maf. Link defended Mobi, but he also was against d2d...