Elements Mafia 71 - by Submachine

[Calindu]

I doubt anyone is committed enough to use the 'who' function in that way, it would basically require 2 full days of F5'ing, and I doubt the only messages that are being sent around are related to mafia anyway. Also, it's a pretty fun function, you get to see what guests are looking at and which members are feeling nostalgic.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Agree with root. Game just became so much harder with no pms not just because of phoenix but because there cant be a civvy central of nymph confirmed people behind the scene. Timing the release of info by nymph is paramount. Too early and get instakilled, too late and all that info is lost with death. 

[moehrpi]

lol, I just thought it's the same number of mafia as last game. Only now saw that there's 4 of them.

And please don't roleblock random people...

My thought was that everyone should gather as much information themselves as they can since there is no way to share sensitive information until we're in the final stages of the game.

[iancudorinmarian]

I have an idea. We're still going to lynch whoever we want to, but we should have a bunch of random votes as well (and not just 1-offs). The Golden Nymph would vote on who they discovered to be mafia and pretty much leave it at that without trying to push for the lynch.

Then, when the Golden Nymph finally gets nightkilled, we would know a few of the mafia.

Of course, this needs to be done carefully to avoid detection.

[moehrpi]

I have an idea. We're still going to lynch whoever we want to, but we should have a bunch of random votes as well (and not just 1-offs). The Golden Nymph would vote on who they discovered to be mafia and pretty much leave it at that without trying to push for the lynch.

Then, when the Golden Nymph finally gets nightkilled, we would know a few of the mafia.

Of course, this needs to be done carefully to avoid detection.

I doubt that would work. Nymph would die before he finds out a second mafia.

[MasterWalks]

I'm thinking GN should probably reveal if they find 2 or more mafia

[Espithel]

In case you are subtly trying to incriminate me as the only message sender, I was giving shock deckadvice completely unrelated to this game. He can probably vouch for that.

No incrimination attempt intended. Really sorry if it came out like that. I had another screenshot prepared, but then I saw Walk's nothing, or nothing you could see and decided to use that one to be consistent and stop people asking why it's two different screenies.

That also means I can vouch for you.

:^)


Ultimately, the information you get from this is pretty small, even if you mash F5 - it'll all be circumstantial evidence. But information is king in Mafia, and this gives millions of tiny pebbles of information that you shouldn't have.
So I'm going to hold true to my values and stop using it. I hope. It's kinda addicting.

-

As for Golden Nymph, what stops her from roleclaiming and being backed up by a heal/guard? It's just that the heal/guard could be mafia, right?

[moehrpi]

Golden Nymph cannot be protected.

[Espithel]

I asked that, too. Didn't I.

I'm stupid.

[PlayerOa]

There's staff work, there's PvP, there's soon to be Brawl, there's random chitchat a là kaempfer and shock... continuously monitoring Who's Online won't help us a single bit. Not like banning it would be possible by any means, anyway.

[Mobian]

There's staff work, there's PvP, there's soon to be Brawl, there's random chitchat a là kaempfer and shock... continuously monitoring Who's Online won't help us a single bit. Not like banning it would be possible by any means, anyway.

Agreed, especially given how there's more going on in these forums besides our mafia game. Other than that, I agree with playjng it cool with ability usage while we gather more intel.

[RootRanger]

I have an idea. We're still going to lynch whoever we want to, but we should have a bunch of random votes as well (and not just 1-offs). The Golden Nymph would vote on who they discovered to be mafia and pretty much leave it at that without trying to push for the lynch.

Then, when the Golden Nymph finally gets nightkilled, we would know a few of the mafia.

Of course, this needs to be done carefully to avoid detection.

+1 to this. Worst case, GN ends up not  finding mafia and voting on randoms, which would be no better than what we'd have anyways.