Elements Mafia 70 - by Linkcat

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Sent role

[mathman101]

Sent role

[iancudorinmarian]

Sending roles to Root is pretty much pointless unless you have an information role. Anyway, sent.

[dawn to dusk]

Any role is information for Root
Especially for stuff like Psion and the like

[iancudorinmarian]

Any role is information for Root
Especially for stuff like Psion and the like

How come? It's unlikely that mafia would even want to lie about their secondary role, since there aren't separate role for mafia/civvy.

[InsignificantWeeaboo]

Sent role

[Mobian]

Sent mine last night.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Any role is information for Root
Especially for stuff like Psion and the like

How come? It's unlikely that mafia would even want to lie about their secondary role, since there aren't separate role for mafia/civvy.

Root will be a pool of information. At some point an ability will be used 'scumilly' so knowing who has whaf ability could be important. Basically knowledge is power.

[MasterWalks]

Role Sent

[Submachine]

Sent role

[Coffeeditto]

role sent

[shockcannon]

I had some issues with lynching Root but it's too late now, so I have a few things to say before this plan goes horribly.  First, following Root's vote is a very questionable strategy when he can't communicate to us. Assuming Golden Nymph has yet to find a mafia, then Root would be basing his vote off purely assumptions and some evidence people provide (which could be false evidence given by mafia). Additionally, if multiple people claim golden nymph then Root basically has to vote for everyone who claims golden nymph, because obviously one or multiple of them are mafia. But then we risk losing the golden nymph very early in exchange for a mafia. This may be worth it but who knows.

Moderator Comment

Hypothetically breaking the rules is not allowed.

Basically, we should be very hesitant to blindly follow Root's vote. If he votes based off what evidence he has but doesn't know for a fact that the person he is voting is a mafia, we could start lynching town unnecessarily. This is why I really don't think we should've lynched Root because his vote doesn't provide us with as much information as you all think it does.

Essentially, I think this idea was terrible but whatever, we're stuck with it. Just don't go lynching random town.