But a scumread without any reason whatsoever is a bad one. I mean, if you were like, 'I get a sketchy vibe from JCJ', that might be cool, but not with no backing whatsoever.
A scumread that's just 'he feels sketchy' is weak, but not necessarily bad. Intuition is important in mafia, generally.
Not saying I don't still believe it. You have one of my highest townreads right now Coffee. Don't ruin it.
Noting this post (and the interaction around it) to be considered for read analysis later. No read from it at present, but it's striking me as curious. I'm not positive I've ever seen anything quite like it, certainly not in forum-based mafia.