Elements Mafia 63 - by skyironsword

[Demagog]

That's not the only role I've talked about, andre.

My ability to contribute comes after a few rounds, as I base it on voting behavior and how the game has gone so far. Literally nothing has happened yet, so I can't come to any conclusions. The only thing I've noticed is Lunaris hasn't really said anything despite the bit of pressure. In fact, Lunaris has had only one post, the signup post. At this point, I don't expect Lunaris to contribute this game.

[Ryli]

rob77dp (1) - Linkcat
fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (1) - RavingRabbid
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (4) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil

A non contributing power role isn't very helpful, so it's the best option for now, I do not support a Demagog lynch this early, especially not after what happened with Rob last game.

[Linkcat]

rob77dp (1) - Linkcat
fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (1) - RavingRabbid
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (4) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil
No Lynch (1) - Linkcat

Please keep the total updated.

[Ryli]

Sorry, I copied the latest list and added myself. No Lynch wasn't on there.

[Linkcat]

It's understandable.

[andretimpa]

That's not the only role I've talked about, andre.

+ watermelon then?

My ability to contribute comes after a few rounds, as I base it on voting behavior and how the game has gone so far. Literally nothing has happened yet, so I can't come to any conclusions. The only thing I've noticed is Lunaris hasn't really said anything despite the bit of pressure. In fact, Lunaris has had only one post, the signup post. At this point, I don't expect Lunaris to contribute this game.

2 posts (kinky = Lunaris). He also voted in Sol for shits and giggles

mathman101 [1] - ddevans96
rob77dp [1] - Linkcat
fabian771 [1] - mathman101
ddevans96 [1] - Demagog
Kuroaitou [1] - RavingRabbid
Solaris [1] - Lunaris

The moon will forever reign!

I'll join the train for now, but I don't think Lunaris has come online since we piled on her, which would explain the silence.

rob77dp (1) - Linkcat
fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (1) - RavingRabbid
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (5) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli, andretimpa
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil
No Lynch (1) - Linkcat

[UTAlan]

fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (1) - RavingRabbid
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (5) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli, andretimpa
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil
No Lynch (1) - Linkcat

Fixing the vote total. Link only gets 1 vote as far as I am aware.

[Ryli]

He cant help it, it's his Odd-Even thing, he forgets he's only 1 person with 1 vote.

[UTAlan]

At that point you should lynch someone that you think won't contribute, not someone who can do you a lot of good when they are town.

This is actually a decent suggestion. I know No Lynch is typically more favorable for mafia than town, but I also know I suck at scumreading and we have zero info to go on D1 other than scumreading. Not sure how to reconcile this except for the above. Going after someone with no posts since signing up is as good a plan as any.

fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (1) - RavingRabbid
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (6) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli, andretimpa, UTAlan
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil
No Lynch (1) - Linkcat

As always, I'm open to changing my mind if anyone has any evidence worth considering (or if Lunaris shows up and provides an explanation for inactivity to this point and assurance that it'll change going forward). Also, Dema is not cleared in the least, but neither is he suspicious. Everyone is neutral to me at this point.

[Solaris]

At that point you should lynch someone that you think won't contribute, not someone who can do you a lot of good when they are town.

This is actually a decent suggestion. I know No Lynch is typically more favorable for mafia than town, but I also know I suck at scumreading and we have zero info to go on D1 other than scumreading. Not sure how to reconcile this except for the above. Going after someone with no posts since signing up is as good a plan as any.

fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (1) - RavingRabbid
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (6) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli, andretimpa, UTAlan
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil
No Lynch (1) - Linkcat

As always, I'm open to changing my mind if anyone has any evidence worth considering (or if Lunaris shows up and provides an explanation for inactivity to this point and assurance that it'll change going forward). Also, Dema is not cleared in the least, but neither is he suspicious. Everyone is neutral to me at this point.

I've been more inactive than Lunaris. What is this clownfiesta?

[Solaris]

nvm we both had 2 posts at the time

[Linkcat]

So we have our votes on two people right now. First is Dema, who has votes because he's irritating, but lynching Dema Day 1 for basically nothing is beyond insane.

Then we have Lunaris, who has votes for literally nothing, considering she hasn't even posted yet. The only reason is because Dema picked her randomly, so I find it really interesting that Ryli said that she didn't want Dema to decide the lynch, then went ahead and voted with him anyway. Lunaris having low activity is not a valid reason to vote on her because she has always had low activity on the weekends, it's been brought up in mafia before.

So since both of these lynches are terrible, I'm going to go with who I think is mafia, because a tiny reason is better than no reason.

First is Ryli for what I just said, and because her calling for everyone to throw single votes around and then backpeddling on it was weird.

Next is rob for not putting down a vote, or posting more than once. It's even a dueling phase.

Last is Kuro for throwing a single vote on danil without even posting anything.

Since Kuro is the only one with votes, I'm going with him. Kuro is also a good Day 1 lynch because he's pretty useless as town, but really dangerous as mafia.

fabian771 (1) - mathman101
Kuroaitou (2) - RavingRabbid, Linkcat
Solaris (1) - Lunaris
Demagog (4) - dawn to dusk, JonathanCrazyJ, ddevans96, CleanOnion
Lunaris (6) - iancudorinmarian, Demagog, Submachine, Ryli, andretimpa, UTAlan
dawn to dusk (1) - fabian771
danil (1) - Kuroaitou
kirbylover314 (1) - danil