Time to bring up stuff from 20 pages ago that's probably not even relevant anymore.
She has recently returned to forums after a long hiatus, so as such she's unfamiliar with, at the very least, how the culture of mafia in this community has changed, if not rusty in mafia as a whole if she has not played offsite. I would expect a mafia in this situation to be more reserved, more passive, and following the leads of her scummates more. But she has the second most posts in this thread - a handful of them are questionable posts, and do lean the dial slightly back towards scum, but again that's not what I would expect of a returning player assigned to mafia, I think her scummates would have dialed her back before now.
Ryli was mafia last game, and I'm getting a similar kind of general read as I did that game.
Rob, dd, Dema, tell me what you think about Ryli.
Ok, but item 0 - why did you select that group to ask this question of?
The three of you were online at the time and I wanted to get opinions from other players.
-
When I said that lynching Dema Day 1 was a bad idea, I didn't mean that we should avoid lynching him because he's a good player, I meant that on Day 1 it's very difficult to get any kind of read on a player like Dema on Day 1. There are exceptions, like when I lynched rob last mafia, but generally it's not going to be any more effective than an RNGed lynch. Dema's lists are completely pointless and useless and always have been.
-
RIP Kuro, you think you guys would have learned by now to not let me pick the Day 1 lynch.
sky doesn't insult others.
This is the most ridiculous statement I've ever read in a mafia game.
-
Trying to use people defending a town player as a read is silly, and saying that w3 is using that as a point in his favor when he clearly isn't is also silly. The reason I said w3 was town is because I liked how he ignored Kuro and Dema in favor of pushing his own read on Ryli, who I was also suspicious of. I actually wanted to lynch Ryli that day, but I thought trying to move the votes then would just end up with Dema being lynched. W3 saying he didn't vote Dema because he was afraid of being lynched seems sketchy, but if you think about it, it's coming from a town perspective.
-
Rob, I haven't pushed on you this game because this is the first game we've played together that I haven't scumread you, as town, mafia, or the host.
And I'm scumreading you for that. You should be glad. Your scumread on Sub is bad considering he changes his playstyle every game.
-
Pretty much everything after that was stuff I didn't care enough to spend time posting about.
w3 is clearly town, and I wanted to lynch Ryli anyway.
worldwideweb3 (3) - Solaris, JonathanCrazyJ, iancudorinmarian
Ryli (3) - worldwideweb3, Espithel, Linkcat
Demagog (1) - Ryli
kirbylover314 (2) - UTAlan, rob77dp
