Elements Mafia 62 - by Solaris

[Linkcat]

Because he's mafia.

So Dema, how do you feel about lynching Onion tomorrow?

Wouldn't it be easier to kill me tonight?

That's just not quite as fun.

Also we need to find out who has the other rock. Sera?

[Espithel]

Because he's mafia.

No no no no no no no.

Why is he mafia?

[Linkcat]

His play during this game doesn't make sense as town.

[Espithel]

His play during this game doesn't make sense as town.

Can you quote examples?

[Demagog]

Because he's mafia.

So Dema, how do you feel about lynching Onion tomorrow?

Wouldn't it be easier to kill me tonight?

That's just not quite as fun.

Also we need to find out who has the other rock. Sera?

IMO all of you are equally likely to be mafia. I have my suspicions, which I believe I've already made clear. Town is starting to throw the game with no lynches though, so w/e. Let's just lynch someone and play the game.

You say his play doesn't make sense as town, but I can't think of anything off the top of my head. Give us some examples.

[Espithel]

IMO all of you are equally likely to be mafia. I have my suspicions, which I believe I've already made clear. Town is starting to throw the game with no lynches though, so w/e. Let's just lynch someone and play the game.

You say his play doesn't make sense as town, but I can't think of anything off the top of my head. Give us some examples.

This is the most town thing you have said thus far.

[Espithel]

And I wholeheartedly agree with it.

[Demagog]

No Espi keep accusing me so mafia won't kill me! Everything I say is town-like because I am town :-p

[Espithel]

Shit Demagog has seen through my plans now he's gonna get nk'd [/s]

[Linkcat]

Demagog being confirmed by two nightkills being old players is completely ridiculous.

Your explanation is not bad either - it explains the kill very well.

In fact it almost looks like the nightkill was selected simply so Link could somehow say Dema is town. This is horribly WIFOM-y which only makes me want to decide on other factors more, i.e. Link jumping on dawn.

Let's start with this clear contradiction that he failed to address. In the same post he claims that my explanation is completely ridiculous and that it explains the kill very well. Of course he'll try to put a spin on it, but that doesn't change the fact that it happened.

[Demagog]

Maybe he meant that your idea that either mafia killed KDZ to frame me or that I'm mafia and killed him to make it look like mafia is trying to frame me has merit. But that doesn't mean that I'm confirmed town. That's how I understood it and I don't see it as a contradiction.

[Linkcat]

It's a complete turnaround from the idea to the logical conclusion of the idea. Onion, how would you feel about it if I die and flip town?