Elements Mafia 62 - by Solaris

[Solaris]

A rock with a note only gives the name of the thrower.

[rob77dp]

CleO, I goofed and thought the Rock revealed name AND alignment... You Ann's Dema are right, rock seems mostly useless given how our does work (name only).

[Linkcat]

Toss the rocks around and hope they get to Artemis. She can then throw the rocks to the people she investigates, so that if she's Nightkilled we have some idea of who she targeted. That means don't give rocks to me, or any of the mafia like rob. Artemis should still breadcrumb her targets. Fake breadcrumbs from other players will also help.

[Espithel]

Here, I'll post a list. The higher someone is on the list, they more likely they are to be nightkilled in general. This also means that the longer the game goes on, the higher someone is on the list, the more likely they are to be mafia than someone that is lower on the list.

Do you want me to hound you?

[CleanOnion]

Toss the rocks around and hope they get to Artemis. She can then throw the rocks to the people she investigates, so that if she's Nightkilled we have some idea of who she targeted. That means don't give rocks to me, or any of the mafia like rob. Artemis should still breadcrumb her targets. Fake breadcrumbs from other players will also help.

Wouldn't Artemis need to be confirmed in order for the Rock recipients to have any clue of their significance?
And if she's confirmed, or known to be Artemis, she may as well just post in the thread anyway.

[Demagog]

Link, how will we know Artemis got the rocks?

Only thing we can do is have whoever threw the rock and whoever got hit confirm in thread. We can keep a list of who's been involved in the rock chains. If Artemis dies and turns out that they are in the rock chains, and Artemis tossed rock(s) to people that have been confirmed civs by On the Hunt, we can get some confirmed civs.

So the plan works I think; Artemis has to just only throw rocks to people that have been confirmed.

On another note, if anyone uses Brick and Mortar on someone you aren't 100% sure is mafia and you two are able to keep it secret, the longer the two of you are both alive, the more likely the other person is mafia (if you are civilian).

[rob77dp]

Toss the rocks around and hope they get to Artemis. She can then throw the rocks to the people she investigates, so that if she's Nightkilled we have some idea of who she targeted. That means don't give rocks to me, or any of the mafia like rob. Artemis should still breadcrumb her targets. Fake breadcrumbs from other players will also help.

*sigh* we ARE going to have this again, Lc? If you are mafia, and town heeds Dema's advice regarding you and I, then you are playing very bad as mafia (we both know a town/rob will is not likely to live very ling). If you are town then I have no good idea why you would open with such a hard and unfounded claim against me?

[Demagog]

EBWOP:  "anyone uses Brick and Mortar on someone you aren't 100% sure is civilian "

Meant to say civilian in that previous post.

[Demagog]

Whoever throws rocks this round, don't reveal who you are throwing to until after the night phase is over.

We may want to avoid lynching whoever has the rocks. They may be instrumental in victory after all. Due to the priority of actions, mafia can only get rid of rocks if they happen to kill the person that got hit by a rock that night phase. The other ways to lose rocks are by lynches and modkills.

[iancudorinmarian]

Why do we even care about the rocks?

[danil]

Here, I'll post a list. The higher someone is on the list, they more likely they are to be nightkilled in general. This also means that the longer the game goes on, the higher someone is on the list, the more likely they are to be mafia than someone that is lower on the list.


1. Demagog
2. Linkcat
3. killsdazombies
4. rob77dp
5. Kuroaitou
6. RavingRabbid
7. UTAlan
8. Sera
9. skyironsword
10. DoubleCapitals
11. Ginyu
12. dawn to dusk
13. Espithel
14. fabian771
15. 1011686
16. iancudorinmarian
17. Ryli
18. Danil
19. CleanOnion

I have no experience with Mafia, how did you decide upon this list?

[rob77dp]

We need to be careful about HOW information is revealed in the thread from role and item usage (note that revealing info is good I am simply advocating caution in the how).

Wreckless posting of information might lead to mafia having an easier time hunting power roles and knowing who certain items are sitting with...

Why do we even care about the rocks?

-->

Toss the rocks around and hope they get to Artemis. She can then throw the rocks to the people she investigates, so that if she's Nightkilled we have some idea of who she targeted. That means don't give rocks to me, or any of the mafia like rob. Artemis should still breadcrumb her targets. Fake breadcrumbs from other players will also help.