who thought a 5 way tie is good for town
Nobody that I saw/read -- it was mentioned a few times that ties are currently present and that a tie is NL and NL is not a good idea for town here. Were you going to jump out of the relative shadows / corner onto someone for mentioning ties in a way construable as "good for town"?
Not related to ian's most recent post, but something I realized this mafia is that about half of Link's posts that seem serious are actually jokes and not to be taken seriously. Reminds me of my father-in-law who loves to tell jokes by starting with a story that sounds serious but ends in a pun.
Cool story bro. -- -- -- was your father-in-law mafia or town in the end?
Notes:
* higher within a grouping generally indicates more town-y among that group
* absent from the list means either I forgot to include them or (more likely) very few posts or "no read" (null) on them from me so far
* vv = I consider them HIGHLY villager-y (i.e. - very likely town in my view); ww = I consider them HIGHLY wolf-y (i.e. - very likely scum / mafia in my view); the list is a scale from vv --> ww where 'n' = "neutral"* WHITE text indicates new additions to the content
vv:none yet
v:Espithel - some quick hit posts, some wall posts, all containing responses and plans that come off town to me.
Volume trailing off but still same read at this time.Demagog - plans of action so far have felt pro-town; has always been town in games I've played and this so far does match his town-game VERY well.
I envision a game state where Lc/Dema are unlikely to be w/w and about equally likely w/v or v/w or v/v. 2/3 of these are Dema as town = stays put right here.UTAlan -
from UTA, I find his "I won't post much this game because I didn't win/perform well last game" a tad ~furry for my taste. Nice response from UTA on my push and appears to be analyzing thread contents best he can. Sizeable town bump from me!n:CleanOnion -
null... volume but nothing good enough to read. He is responding to pokes in the thread and seemingly keeping up with most of the thread/content but that vote on Lc was a tad awkward.danil - responded 'OK' to the push about "new", so far.
Sera - mid-level volume and nothing of note to read yet, from my view.
More of the same...iancu -
beginning involvement here at start of D1 but not enough to read much yet (poking Kuro for activity bodes well though) I consider blindly following someone else's vote, especially a player like Lc known for scummy-town and towny-scum tendencies (good players tend to have this trait?), this early in the game just because you have no idea to be a bit less-than-town.DoubleCapitals - volume of posts is good but content/quality is lacking and nothing of note to me so far.
<-- This is still happening... DC, I experienced you playing that was last game as mafia - but also I recall you sometimes play this was as town. A bump in the scum direction for now...w:Kuro -
The more I consider Kuro's activity level (very present on his other usual duties... absent this game) the more I am suspect of him. Silent/Kuro I view as tending towards the mafia/Kuro end of the spectrum. I see a few of Kuro's attempts to find dirt on other players as stretching posts or statements in the thread and painting-them-as-scummy beyond where town/Kuro would normally go. This I see as not a method or tactic Kuro used in prior games I have read either town or mafia alignment. Therefore, I
Linkcat - *sigh*, I pause to go to hard on this read yet... but for reasons about his pushes on my very basic pushes lean me this way.
His dogged persistence on hounding me, a player showing consistent in-thread desire to analyze and be present pressuring others for input (which is information - now or later) and giving my thoughts and input as well. ww:none yet
Edit notes: ~ UTA from w to v.
~ DC and ian downgrades within same grouping.
~ Other various comments added.
