Elements Mafia 59 - by RootRanger

[mathman101]

My apologies, but I think I am even more confused now.

I see how rob is confirmed civ (mafia can't NK target their own players and he was saved by Goldstein), but how were you and sky confirmed? If it is just your assumption or gut feeling, then I don't think that is confirmed, but if it was stated somewhere and I missed it, could you please point it out?

Also not sure what you mean by civy central, as I thought that all communications was only through here. except for mafia having a separate pad, and the 2 secret notes being passed around which only allow pms but not an actually civ central.

[killsdazombies]

Chat conversations posted

[18:28:14] ‹killsdazombies› So kinky, any thoughts on the current mafia situation (I'll copy pasta into thread if so)
[18:28:24] worldwideweb3 left.
[18:30:03] ‹AveragePotato› The latest forum post is Re: Art Competition: Paint With Elements - Th... from Krzysiekxd. Didn't you read this already?
[18:30:06] ‹kinkykitten624› Not a huge fan of the tie voting thing going on. Seems like kind of a waste of time to me
[18:30:57] ‹killsdazombies› For sure, the tie is essentially a forfeit for civies
[18:31:34] ‹kinkykitten624› Those were my thoughts as well
[18:31:44] ‹kinkykitten624› Seems almost pointless, really
[18:31:53] ‹chrispybacon84› I'm out, bye chat
[18:32:01] ‹kinkykitten624› We may as well all be voting for no lynch
[18:32:03] ‹chrispybacon84› ‹@kinkykitten624› Also, hey! Haven't seen you in a while
[18:32:05] ‹kinkykitten624› Bye chrispy
[18:32:11] ‹kinkykitten624› ‹@chrispybacon84› Hi
[18:32:19] ‹killsdazombies› Were voting for "Town lynch" not no lynch
[18:32:49] ‹kinkykitten624› True
[18:33:05] chrispybacon84 left.
[18:33:16] ji412jo joined.
[18:33:13] ‹ji412jo› ‹@JonathanCrazyJ› will you win already
[18:33:51] ‹ji412jo› No lynch is the worst vote you can make in a mafia game.
[18:34:22] ‹killsdazombies› Were not doing no lynch
[18:34:25] ‹killsdazombies› Were doing town lynch
[18:34:56] ‹kinkykitten624› No lynch would be better than what we're doing currently

[killsdazombies]

Me and sky are not confirmed, just confirmed to me.


Civy central in this case just means the group that winston has gathered, true they are not in contact (probably) but winston has a list of names (hopefully) one of whom, might be mafia (O'brien and all)

[skyironsword]

I cannot help but notice that no one is voting properly yet.

Therefore, I can only assume we've reached some sort of peace treaty. Would anyone like tea and crumpets?

[rob77dp]

killsdazombies [2] - Solaris, kinkykitten624
CleanOnion [3] - skyironsword, killsdazombies, rob77dp
rob77dp [1] - CleanOnion
skyironsword [2] - Calindu, mathman101

Here's hoping IP are not using Gin this day phase, right?  Winston, you're claiming services are going to be needed soon. (A)I think that if Winston thinks they may die this lynch (Gin and such other nonsense - not sure how you'd "know" beyond just suspecting... ...) then put it out there now (/A) otherwise wait until this night phase to hit Brotherhood with your findings.

Brotherhood hint: we gotta get this vote to a margin of at least 5 votes to ensure the target is the lynched party in the case we are hitting an IP member... the Gin means a 4-margin goes to tie and tie kills the Brotherhood member not IP.

My case against CO basically lies on the foundation set up by kdz:
kdz #1
kdz#2
kdz#3
kdz#4


Also, I think only one BH member could get away with this logic of CO valuing his own life above that of another playing being heavily considered as BH... Refer to item marked (A) above here then.

[rob77dp]

Aside: [I had trouble finding the most recent previous vote so please correct my vote tally if incorrect...]

[CleanOnion]

I'm fairly sure Day 3 ended several hours ago

[mathman101]

I'm fairly sure Day 3 ended several hours ago

Day 4 is begun. Day 4 has ended.

[rob77dp]

Anyone else online to help investigate post #'s:

262 - www3 (dead BH) votes jippy (dead BH) up to math's-total+1
264 - Cal (alive) votes math (alive) up to tie jippy and math
266 - Solaris (alive) votes jippy up to math's-total+1
267 - Zawadx (alive) votes math up to tie jippy and math
271 - rob (me, on-my-second-life-and-am-BH) votes jippy up to math's-total+1
276 - kinkykitten (alive) votes math up to tie jippy and math
277 - math votes jippy up to his-own-total+1

What I see here _could_ be IP trying to keep an IP member out of a two-way-tie with a non-IP.  That is, we now know jippy as Brotherhood... if it ends up tied with not much said about math and jippy dies it turns into some saying jippy lost the random between two BH and some saying jippy lost the tie due to math being IP.  Anybody with better mafia-playing skills than I have some quick time to analyze and repost their findings here ASAP?

[rob77dp]

I may see it now... WP IP? Hopefully not what I just realized though...

[RootRanger]

Someone might have died, or disappeared. You’ve stopped paying attention. You notice that your vanilla ration has been slowly decreasing.

CleanOnion has been lynched. He was a Vanilla Brotherhood. He was found with no items.

Night 5 is begun. Night 5 has ended.

The remaining players are 4 Inner Party, 7 Vanilla Brotherhood, and 1 Winston.

Spoiler for Remaining Players:

1.) Zawadx
2.) Solaris
3.) godisnowonline
7.) Ginyu
10.) Physsion
11.) mathman101
12.) killsdazombies
13.) kinkykitten624
16.) rob77dp
17.) Calindu
19.) dawn to dusk
21.) skyironsword

[CleanOnion]

#UnintentionallyGamethrowing

Yay for reverse psychology that backfires