Elements Mafia 58 - by skyironsword

[ddevans96]

Still alive: Link, kinky, Kuro, me, d2d, dd. I think.

kinkykitten624 was murdered. She was the Newsletter Writer.

[CleanOnion]

Still alive: Link, kinky, Kuro, me, d2d, dd. I think.

I'm unsure who to go for here.

Blame the patriarchy

So, 2 peacekeepers. We can assume there aren't 3 because then they would be in majority and we would lose, assuming that's how sky's game works (which it might not). So uh. We gotta vote. But who for?

[ddevans96]

Rereading the thread, I'm most sure of one thing. I pose it as a discussion.

Either CO or Link is mafia.

Anyone who disagrees, explain why. Anyone who agrees, explain why. Town loses this game if talking doesn't happen immediately.

[dawn to dusk]

I'll talk in about an hour, posting now just in case I won't

[Linkcat]

Either CO or Link is mafia.

I'd like to hear your reasoning on this before I talk about it.

I suppose this is a good time to let you all know that I'm Brawlmaster, so lynching me is not a great idea.

I'm just going to throw out a vote for now.

ddevans96 (1) - Linkcat

[CleanOnion]

Bullshit. You're just trying to protect yourself.

ddevans96 (1) - Linkcat
Linkcat [1] - CleanOnion

[CleanOnion]

Ugh, splitting the voting isn't going to get anybody lynched

ddevans96 (2) - Linkcat, CleanOnion

[ddevans96]

I'd like to hear your reasoning on this before I talk about it.

Because your potential scumtells overlap. I can elaborate if you want me to.

Lynching me is confusing to me - most of the attempts to push the game forward have been done by me. I'd argue we'd have won already if there was more cooperation.

ddevans96 (2) - Linkcat, CleanOnion
Linkcat (1) - ddevans96

We lose the game if I'm lynched, that's my only certainty. So I won't be voting for myself. That leaves either you or CO, really.

dawn, Kuro, start talking please.

[ddevans96]

For clarity - overlap the most*

[skyironsword]

Game doesn't end while it is still possible to lynch mafia.

Majority is irrelevant.

[Linkcat]

I'd like to hear your reasoning on this before I talk about it.

Because your potential scumtells overlap. I can elaborate if you want me to.

Please do.

Lynching me is confusing to me - most of the attempts to push the game forward have been done by me.

That's just false. You haven't done much until today.

[dawn to dusk]

Lynching Link isn't a great idea. I'm not defending him, but it would be better to lynch him later, say at LyLo (which, for the sakes of this post, is assuming 3 mafia). Either he is mafia and we get another day, or he is Brawlmaster, and we hope he snipes mafia. The reason I say to kill him later is because he has a better chance of sniping, the fewer civilians are left. That being said, nobody has counterclaimed him, so I am not really willing to think he is not mafia.

I think it goes without saying, but just in case, if you CAN counterclaim, please do.

dd is probably not mafia either, as there would be no reason for mafia to try to act civvy at this stage of the game, but rather just blend into the crowd.