Elements Mafia 56 - by mathman101

[Solaris]

killsdazombies (1) - JonathanCrazyJ[
Skyironsword (1) - Killsdazombies

Somehow hit the size button apparently. Heres the vote that should have beenon the last post[/font]

FTFY

[Submachine]

killsdazombies (1) - JonathanCrazyJ
Skyironsword (1) - Killsdazombies

I'm fixing it.

[Submachine]

-- It so happens that it is a handy one that would get me killed if it were revealed to Mafia. --

So, I may point it out that when I first read this, I didn't know what to say. If your role was so useful that you cannot reveal it to the mafia, why did you reveal it publicly? At first I thought that you are just new and you don't know that you draw mafia's attention to your ability if you say things like this.

Now that you didn't die after that claim, it's fairly suspicious that you might be mafia after all. Why would you publicly claim that you are one role we shouldn't kill, if not because you already know that you cannot be killed by the mafia? It would make the most sense.

[Anastasia]

Currently I exist in a Schödinger state. It is up to the mafia to decide if my potential ability is threatening enough to kill me over another player, but revealing it certainly would get me killed.

Consider that I am mafia. Why did I vote no lynch the first day? I so eloquently put it as "2 civvies > 1 civvy." It wouldn't be difficult to inspire people with some rhetoric in order to get a lynch going, though that would also get me killed if I named someone incorrectly. Mafia is a dangerous game, dead one way or another.

However, in this scenario, I suppose that I got lucky enough that Linkcat was seen as a threat over what my potential ability was; he was successful enough in the previous games with his follow-the-leader tactic that so many complained of. I would speculate to some extent that possibly one of the previous mafia is also mafia this round, especially a player who has faced Linkcat before.

I know exactly how to play mafia. The question is, do you? I'd like to see some respite from my continuous interrogations to see what you have in your own defense. The offensive only works for so long.

[skyironsword]

killsdazombies (1) - JonathanCrazyJ
skyironsword (1) - killsdazombies
Submachine (1) - skyironsword

[JonathanCrazyJ]

skyironsword (2) - killsdazombies, JonathanCrazyJ
Submachine (1) - skyironsword

Sub's argument was totally valid. Saying "I have  an important role" is basically as much of a givaway as saying exactly what your role is. However, I don't disagree with Anastasia's defense.
What I do disagree with is sky jumping on Sub, considering his argument was totally valid. I found it weird her voting on Linkcat, who was one of the MVPs last game, and now, with very, very little provocation, she's jumping on the other one?

[CrockettRocket]

PS Its Anastasia's turn to randomize 2 people and ask them both questions.
skyironsword (2) - killsdazombies, JonathanCrazyJ
Submachine (2) - skyironsword, CrockettRocket

[skyironsword]

Sub's argument was totally valid. Saying "I have  an important role" is basically as much of a givaway as saying exactly what your role is. However, I don't disagree with Anastasia's defense.
What I do disagree with is sky jumping on Sub, considering his argument was totally valid. I found it weird her voting on Linkcat, who was one of the MVPs last game, and now, with very, very little provocation, she's jumping on the other one?

I'm actually just voting on people I don't like.

[Anastasia]

My turn, let's see.

MeowMeowCat
Submachine

If you were mafia, which person would be the next night kill and why?

[Lunaris]

skyironsword (3) - killsdazombies, JonathanCrazyJ, kinkykitten624
Submachine (2) - skyironsword, CrockettRocket

I cannot believe that sky is innocent in this. 

[Anastasia]

I am fairly certain sky is innocent. It would be easy to cast doubt by killing the ones she votes for, though that effect seems unintended. Be careful with mob lynching.

Moderator Comment

The contents of this post are void due to breaking the EBWOP rule. Do not modify your posts people!

[Lunaris]

I am fairly certain sky is innocent. It would be easy to cast doubt by killing the ones she votes for, though that effect seems unintended. Be careful with mob lynching.

Where exactly does this certainty come from?