Elements Mafia 56 - by mathman101

[Lunaris]

I like this method, it could prove to be incredibly useful. However, what happens if both refuse to answer the question, or are inactive in the time between the question being asked and the next lynch? And plus, wouldn't this be a good way to reveal who was civvy to mafia? Its suicide.

No Lynch (4) - Linkcat, UTAlan, Arum, kinkykitten624
Linkcat (1) - skyironsword
killsdazombies (1) - JonathanCrazyJ
JonathanCrazyJ(1) - Killsdazombies

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Mafia knows who all the civvies are. They are the ones who aren't mafia.

[Lunaris]

Yeah... I had a blonde moment. My bad

[mathman101]

This one from the rules:

5. All player roles, targeting, and actions will take effect during the Night Phase, unless stated otherwise.

Does a no lynch vote have any power? AKA. If there are more votes on No lynch than on any other people, is the lynch cancelled? To me, no lynch means the same as not posting anything, it's just for letting the others know that you are not inactive, you just don't want to lynch anyone specific.

4. Voting for no lynch in a day is an option. If you wish to vote for no lynch, you should declare this as such.

If there are more votes on No Lynch then on any person, then yes there will be no lynch during that day.
No Vote and No Lynch are different however; No Vote is the same as not posting at all, and No Lynch is not lynching anyone during that day.

I hope this helps clarify it.

[CrockettRocket]

Afterward the first person interrogated gets to randomize the next 2 people for questioning. If only 1 person asks all the questions and theyre mafia it wouldn't be of any use.

[Anastasia]

2 civvies dead > 1 civvie dead.

Plus, what kind of logic can you use on the first day? Stupid logic, mostly.

No Lynch (5) - Linkcat, UTAlan, Arum, kinkykitten624, Anastasia.
Linkcat (1) - skyironsword
killsdazombies (1) - JonathanCrazyJ
JonathanCrazyJ(1) - Killsdazombies

[Naesala]

No Lynch (5) - Linkcat, UTAlan, Arum, kinkykitten624, Anastasia.
Linkcat (1) - skyironsword
killsdazombies (2) - JonathanCrazyJ, Naesala
JonathanCrazyJ(1) - Killsdazombies

Each day, someone should pick 2 people from the signup list. Ask them a RELEVANT question, then interrogate them.

Anastasia
Naesala

Here is the first question to you: How would you prove your worth if you were assumed to be mafia? It is a live-or-die situation.

If I were on the chopping block, I'd roleclaim. If I were mafia, I might falsely roleclaim. I'd also point out flaws in any argument to lynch me.This answer is for this specific mafia.

[Submachine]

Thank you Nae. It looks like our other participant is less observant.

[Anastasia]

Apologies. I wasn't aware that I had to be on these forums 24/7.

If I were assumed to be Mafia, I would use my skill. It so happens that it is a handy one that would get me killed if it were revealed to Mafia. Additionally, Naesala is correct; a roleclaim on the edge of death would definitely delay it, though seeing as my skill is handy, it may not for long.

[Coffeeditto]

No Lynch (6) - Linkcat, UTAlan, Arum, kinkykitten624, Anastasia, Coffeeditto
Linkcat (1) - skyironsword
killsdazombies (2) - JonathanCrazyJ, Naesala
JonathanCrazyJ(1) - Killsdazombies

I think the best idea here would be for Seraph (if he is in the game and a civilian) should check if there's a mafia in entropy; if the answer replied is no, then we can also see if Guardian Angel is in the game (through claims) and have Precognition claim. Then, we can receive 2-3 clears through Precog and Seraph.

[CrockettRocket]

No Lynch (6) - Linkcat, UTAlan, Arum, kinkykitten624, Anastasia, Coffeeditto
Linkcat (1) - skyironsword
killsdazombies (2) - JonathanCrazyJ, Naesala
JonathanCrazyJ(1) - Killsdazombies
UTAlan (1) - CrockettRockett

I dont suppose my vote couldn't count as 2 to make up for not being able to vote on him day 1 last mafia?

[mathman101]

Lab  at school ran a bit later than planned, so Day 1 has an extra 30 minutes to 1 hour until I get home from campus.