Elements Mafia 55 - by Coffeeditto

[Timdood3]

I don't actually know, but I think they had Veigar claim Annie to bait me into having them vote on each other to guarantee a mafia lynch so that Katarina could kill me tonight. Unfortunately I guessed wrong so she'll kill me anyway.

I obviously didn't post the fourth mafia member because I have no idea who it is.

If you actually consider taking that claim seriously then I have no faith in you.

Just tell me how you can be sure which is katarina and which is veigar and I'll drop it entirely.

[Linkcat]

I don't actually know,

[Timdood3]

*walks away grumbling and sits in a corner, still grumbling*

[JonathanCrazyJ]

MMC's claim is insane because if he actually was Zillian, then he just watched as all of our roles were sent to a mafia. Even after my safety countdown in which i said "counterclaim or mafia win."
Soon after the mass roleclaim Linkcat was asking me if i could work out why mafia would claim Rengar and Annie.
Good work Link, 3 mafia lynches incoming.

[Submachine]

If this is true, please explain why you didn't claim until now (instead, letting us all role-claim to mafia and essentially hand the game over to them).

Oh come on, UTA. Don't start believing him now. He's pulling a RootRanger right in front of our eyes. You know.. Mafia 50.. Claiming to be refugee.. He lied.. You must remember, he was even your teammate.

[CrockettRocket]

If the first person lynched isnt a red, then simply lynch link, as hes ensuring us that they're red and knows their roles too!

[Lunaris]

If MMC was Jinx, why in the world would he send a PM to claim that role to ZILLIAN, the most essential role to the civvies? No offense, but you'd have to be plain stupid to believe that someone as smart as MMC wouldn't be able to figure out how bad of an idea that is.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

He might not have, it might have been process of elimination. The mass roleclaim essentially trapped everyone into sending either their own role, or a fake role which would show up as a double, which also looks incriminating.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

EBWOP: Also, he had no way of knowing that Lux's ability would be triggered, meaning the SAFEST thing to do would be to send his real role.

[Lunaris]

I'm honestly not buying the whole Linkcat=Zillian thing to be honest. If he was honestly a civvy, I think he would at least be playing this as a team game, not a follow the leader one.

[killsdazombies]

I'm honestly not buying the whole Linkcat=Zillian thing to be honest. If he was honestly a civvy, I think he would at least be playing this as a team game, not a follow the leader one.

Well, luckily for us the answer will be revealed tomorrow when we kill someone on that list, correct?

[JonathanCrazyJ]

That makes no sense. Mafia is always follow the leader if you have a plan.

Plan >
Civvy Central >
Follow the plans of the civvy central >
Win.

Playing it as a "team game" just gives mafia information that you don't  want them to have.

Also, you could argue we played a team game.
Submachine thought up a plan.
Linkcat had the important role.
I made sure that NOBODY sent roles to linkcat unless nobody counterclaimed him.

IMMEDIATELY after we sent Linkcat our roles, he orchestrated the voting so that Lux's ability would trigger. This confirms him.