Elements Mafia 54 - by theelkspeaks

[JonathanCrazyJ]

dawn to dusk (3)- ddevans96, Espithel, Discord
MeowMeowCat (4) - rob77dp, UTAlan, kinkykitten624, JonathanCrazyJ

sorry cat

[RichardtheDire]

dawn to dusk (3)- ddevans96, Espithel, Discord
MeowMeowCat (5) - rob77dp, UTAlan, kinkykitten624, JonathanCrazyJ, RichardtheDire

[RootRanger]

@Elk are we allowed to vote for no lynch?

[rob77dp]

@Elk are we allowed to vote for no lynch?

Rule 4 indicates we can... from which I would suppose a majority rule on no-lynch would end the day with nobody being lynched...?

[worldwideweb3]

I don't like rng much. I would rather lynch someone who isn't posting much. But for first day, if no lynch is an option, that's probably best.

[RootRanger]

@Elk are we allowed to vote for no lynch?

Rule 4 indicates we can... from which I would suppose a majority rule on no-lynch would end the day with nobody being lynched...?

Right, missed that.

I think we should definitely at least discuss the possibility of a no-lynch. Consider that we will obtain more information after each night phase, and a lynch could end up hurting ourselves.

But if we are to lynch someone, RNG is the best unless it seems someone is obviously mafia.

[rob77dp]

dawn to dusk (3)- ddevans96, Espithel, Discord
MeowMeowCat (4) - UTAlan, kinkykitten624, JonathanCrazyJ, RichardtheDire
No Lynch (1) - rob77dp

Yeah, I'm going to side with no lynch as a good Day 1 option for us townies aka VILLAINS.

[RichardtheDire]

dawn to dusk (3)- ddevans96, Espithel, Discord
MeowMeowCat (3) - UTAlan, kinkykitten624, JonathanCrazyJ
No Lynch (2) - rob77dp, RichardtheDire


Thinking about this, I guess I'll also vote no lynch.

[Naesala]

dawn to dusk (3)- ddevans96, Espithel, Discord
MeowMeowCat (3) - UTAlan, kinkykitten624, JonathanCrazyJ
No Lynch (3) - rob77dp, RichardtheDire, Naesala

[JonathanCrazyJ]

I retain my not liking  no-lynch, especially as we are villains, so opting to not kill someone when we have the chance feels decidedly un-evil.
My vote stays on RNGMMC.

[ddevans96]

No, I didn't take proof. It was never necessary to do so in earlier mafias here, and in fact to do so would be illegal on MafiaScum, as well as every environment I've played in besides this one.

If you don't believe it's random then either ignore or it or use it against me. Find out what ulterior motive I have to want dawn lynched on day one so badly that I call it RNG even if you believe its not.

elk, please clarify No Lynch in the context of this mafia.

[rob77dp]

I retain my not liking  no-lynch, especially as we are villains, so opting to not kill someone when we have the chance feels decidedly un-evil.
My vote stays on RNGMMC.

I find it interesting and somewhat town-disturbing that you place "adhering to villain-ness" above trying to win the game as your main reason for not going No Lynch.