Elements Mafia 54 - by theelkspeaks

[killsdazombies]

I really do not like this sudden culture of wanting to prove RNG.

same. I think its against the spirit of mafia, and frankly I find it to be rule bending. But thats not my call to make.

[worldwideweb3]

That comes across as very suspicious, as you are choosing to lynch a certain person but not an rng person, without having any suspicions.

[ddevans96]

Note that truly random voting, as with the dice tag, is strictly frowned upon. A vote that is demonstrably random carries no motivation to be read into, and is completely informationless. This is not the intent of the "random voting stage".

I agree with kills, it's totally against the spirit of the game. If we were playing irl, and someone rolled a die, or used any other random method to pick their vote, they'd get lynched for not actually caring about the game, and probably wouldn't be invited to play anymore that night. There's no reason it should be allowed here, let alone encouraged.

[ddevans96]

Also if you think it's suspicious, start a lynch on me, that's what it's for.

[Linkcat]

While I agree that just throwing out a truly random vote is meaningless, if someone believes that a random lynch is beneficial to town, which I completely disagree with, there's no reason they shouldn't be able to prove that the lynch is indeed random.

I don't like the way you've been playing this game, but I haven't had a reason to vote on you until now. Putting a vote in the way that you did on somebody who's not likely to defend herself is suspicious to me. Still not a strong case but it's all I've got.

[Linkcat]

RootRanger (1) - worldwideweb3
Discord (1) - ddevans96
ddevans96 (1) - Linkcat

[ddevans96]

What about my play this game do you dislike?

[Linkcat]

I don't have anything specific. I just get a mafia vibe from you. You might call it a hunch.

[Zawadx]

Also if you think it's suspicious, start a lynch on me, that's what it's for.

ok

RootRanger (1) - worldwideweb3
Discord (1) - ddevans96
ddevans96 (2) - Linkcat, Zawadx

Oh, darnit Link >.<

[ddevans96]

You say you don't like the way I've been playing. That's not a hunch, there has to be reasoning behind that or it's an empty statement. You're grasping at straws.

RootRanger (2) - worldwideweb3, ddevans96
ddevans96 (2) - Linkcat, Zawadx

I'd rather not lynch him but I'm the only known villain to myself and I know my death is a step back, so I'll choose to protect myself. Lynch Link if I die anyways.

[Linkcat]

A hunch has no reasoning by definition. That part was a joke anyways. I am not grasping at straws, I already stated that that wasn't enough reason to vote on you. I am voting on you specifically because of your vote on Discord. Also, saying to lynch me if you die just because I voted on you is terrible play.

[ddevans96]

My vote on Discord is exactly the same as www3's vote on Root, except it wouldn't be illegal in most environments.

And no, I want you lynched if I die because your logic is filled with holes, your actions feel inconsistent, and I would not be at surprised if you were mafia taking advantage of a situation to push scumtells on me and get me lynched safely.