So in the end we had 18 people voting. There are 22 players. 4 people didn't vote:
- killsdazombies
- Espithel
- Coffeeditto
- antiaverage
The only person who didn't post anything is
Coffeeditto, but Kuro can speak up for him as a FGO. Coffee can't come online between November 12 and 19, because he couldn't afford cable bills. This is the reason why I'm not saying he's suspicious yet, though it can be a handy excuse if he's FM.
kirbylover314's only post was a
voting post, so he also essentially posted nothing so far.
The only person with only 1 post is
Espithel. That post was a
question only for personal clarification, which looks unrelated to the game. Posting value = 0,5.
People with 2 posts are
killsdazombies, antiaverage, Naesala, eljoemo and mathman101.
- Kdz's first post was an opinion about game mechanics, the second was noticing that the countdown was set wrong. Actual discussion about the game was not started yet.
- AA's first post looks like a simple flavour post, while the second looks like either an attempt to start a bandwagon or a joke. The latter did spark a small conversation.
- Nae's first post was a reference to mafia 51, probably having flashbacks of the whole Fen'Harel case. Her second post was a voting post with small extra content. The only word that was her own in these posts was a reply to flavour, probably playing way too much cautious. Being super cautious is more like a mafia trait, but it's only day 1 yet, so we'll see how things evolve from here.
- eljoe's first post has a humorous Captain Obvious vibe, so I'm calling it a joke post. His second post was a voting post with small extra content. Still hoping to see more of eljoe's personality traits to be able to read him better.
- math's first post was pure voting nothing else, his second post can be called a "bandwagon" on opinions which was more related to the mechanics than the game itself. Actual discussion about the game was not started yet.
People with 3 posts are
MeowMeowCat, dawn to dusk, Ginyu, Calindu, Kuroaitou and skyironsword.
- MMC's first post was simply flavour, his second was EBWOP with more flavour and joking, while his third was only voting. Actual discussion about the game was not started yet.
- dawn's first post was either a joke or a hidden threat depending on what faction he is, his second post was an opinion, and his third can be counted as a pure voting post. He actually did flesh one of his traits a bit, which we need to see more of. It's a start.
- Ginyu's first post was a reply, a correction and a plan in one, his second and third were voting posts with extra content. He did say more than just following a previously stated plan, which is a good start. We'll see how things will evolve from here.
- Calindu's first and second posts were pure voting posts, while his third was joining an "bandwagon" of opinions. 3 posts that are purely just following others, we saw literally nothing of his own personality yet.
- Kuro's first post is a copy of a mafia post, his second is questionable, but the emoticon in the end looks like he's showing worry. And finally his third was mostly his opinion about game mechanics and current roles. To extend this a little bit, Kuro showed even more worry in chat when Dm first announced that he found Linkcat as mafia. He's showing worry towards things that a Lord [LW] shouldn't be worried about, so he walked into a bit suspicious territory. He is one person I'd like to lock in a talking state from now on so we can know more about his current traits.
- sky's first post had a Captain Obvious vibe again, so I'll call it a joke post (if it was serious, it's a neutral post with no value considering that both factions would say this). Her second post was a revelation post which is heavily relevant, but her third was just a voting post. She's really giving us the silent treatment here, but that one revelation post is relevant enough to make that single post enough for the whole game.
Linkcat had 4 posts, just for the record. His
first one was a normal post with normal value, his
second was a voting post with minor extra content, his
third was joining a "bandwagon" of opinions and his
last post was voting with flavour. I'll live with the opportunity and skip examining someone's traits who's about to get revealed anyway.
UTAlan looks like he has 6 posts, but in fact his
third and
fourth are pure voting posts and his
fifth post is only a correction by EBWOP. So his real posting value is around only 3.
Last but not least,
RavingRabbid also has some interesting posts. His
first post is flavour for something that's not even in the game, his
second is pure EBWOP, his
third post is just a clarification reply but is still only flavour, his
fourth is only flavour again, and finally his
fifth is voting with minor extra content. He managed to post 5 times with a posting value around only 0,5.
Now let's organize the raw data somehow. I'll count the posting value of each player. Below is the formula that I will use, which is based on personal deduction, so comments on how to improve it are welcome.
| Posting Value [PV] |
| EBWOP | 0 |
| Correcting unrelated things said by others | 0 |
| Flavour and jokes | 0 |
| Voting | 0 |
| Following a "bandwagon" of opinions | 0 |
| Neutral posts | 0 |
| Voting with minor extra content | 0,5 |
| Answering someone else's questions | 0,5 |
| Things unrelated to the current game but related to mafia games | 0,5 |
| Very short actual content | 0,5 |
| Useful and related opinions | 1 |
| Posts that spark discussion | 1 |
| Previously unstated informations, plans | 4 |
