Elements Mafia 53 - by Zawadx

[Naesala]

Oh, it must be something I didn't see from the original show then. >_>

Quick! Who's a die-hard Game of Thrones fan?

Nope

[Zawadx]

In, Ive seen very little of game of thrones though

Sign-ups are over.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

Lol is that 2 mafias in a row CR has tried to InAfterRoles?

[Dm]

Yes.

[Submachine]

Here is a general suggestion for lynching people. If we don't have any good idea, start lynching the one with the least overall activity.

Why? Because we need to encourage people speaking (unless you want to repeat what happened in last mafia). If people speak more, it's easier to spot suspicious behaviour and lies/misdirections. So whoever contributes the less should become the lynch target - and then of course we'd hear them out if they have any GOOD way to prove their worth behind their lack of voice.

[JonathanCrazyJ]

*JCJ fills thread with innane coments to get his post count up and avoid kill for being a Silent Sister*

But yeah, talking is good.

[Dm]

Honestly I'd just lynch the worst town players first off.

[DoubleCapitals]

Hmm, I sense this mafia would be an exciting one. All the best.

[ddevans96]

Here is a general suggestion for lynching people. If we don't have any good idea, start lynching the one with the least overall activity.

Why? Because we need to encourage people speaking (unless you want to repeat what happened in last mafia). If people speak more, it's easier to spot suspicious behaviour and lies/misdirections. So whoever contributes the less should become the lynch target - and then of course we'd hear them out if they have any GOOD way to prove their worth behind their lack of voice.

The only mafia lynched last game before the game was heavily in mafia's favor was because of activity. I don't see how reiterating this by itself is going to prevemt what happened last game. Town lost last game because of extremely questionable play early, not lack of activity or lack of interpreting activity.

[UTAlan]

I think the idea is a) to encourage activity, and b) if we're gonna lynch blindly, get the ones who are not being helpful to town.

The problem with this logic is that there are players (sky comes to mind) that are actively helping town, but that may not be doing so via posts in the thread.

[worldwideweb3]

I think the idea is a) to encourage activity, and b) if we're gonna lynch blindly, get the ones who are not being helpful to town.

The problem with this logic is that there are players (sky comes to mind) that are actively helping town, but that may not be doing so via posts in the thread.

After last mafia, i wont believe a word sky says.

[Dm]

Why would we even leave sky alive? We should just lynch her day 1.

Come on: She's either useless, mafia, or one of the shittiest towns we've ever seen. Any reason to keep her alive, ever?