Elements Mafia 51 - by Submachine

[AD TienzuStorm]

I have an idea for another lynch option, but the reasoning will barely tread water 

Anything is better than nothing, right?

Also yes, this is a very dumb reason to lynch Nae.

[Solaris]

implying that my reason is any smarter

[AD TienzuStorm]

implying that my reason is any smarter

You don't necessarily have to lynch for it. Just any bit of information can possibly be useful.

[Submachine]

Organizer Note:

People have been asking why their messages were recolored with RED. The answer is, because those are bloodstains. People who die when sending through a message will have their messages stained in blood (Examples so far: The Village Bicycle, Dr Malum CEO of Evil Mafia Inc, Gepato, Yeri.)

Since 3 people out of 4 were complaining about this, I'm willing to change this indication to something else, just please suggest how you'd want to see this indication/what method should i use for this.

[Submachine]

Also, it's worth checking out 'Details, special cases and exceptions' again, because some extra details were added to further clarify how roles interact with each other. You can see the changelog in the bottom of the OP (under signups).

[Kuroaitou]

Naesala (3) - Linkcat, MeowMeowCat, killsdazombies
Linkcat (1) - Naesala

Not voting yet, but just a small thing:


Secret Mafia Name - Player Name:

[Dead + Unverified]
N/A? - godisnowonline
N/A? - skyironsword

[Dead + Verified (via Bloodstains)]:
Gepato - Zawadx
rob77dp - Yeri
The Village Bicycle - JonathanCrazyJ
Dr. Malum, CEO of Evil Mafia Inc. - qwerter

[Supposedly Alive]
Not a Werewolf - ???
Painweaver - ???
JonathanCrazySwag - ???
KakashiHatakeSwag - ??? (Okay, seriously though. :| )
the tailor - ???
Artorias - ???
Fen'Harel - ???


Although it's not necessarily a good thing to reveal everyone's roles with their 'public' name, I just want to clarify whose name is so far associated with who, based on the deaths that have come apparently afterwards. Some of the people hiding under their names seem to be asking the public for help, (Not a Werewolf [lulz], Artorias, potentially 'the tailor'), some of them seem to be directly evil (Fen'Harel, JonathanCrazySwag [bleh]), and some are just... odd as all hell (Painweaver, KakashiHatakeSwag). We should probably be looking at not only when these coded messages are posted, but also what lies within their contents; additionally, how those contents are provided...

[CrockettRocket]

Naesala (3) - Linkcat, MeowMeowCat, killsdazombies
Linkcat (2) - Naesala, CrockettRocket

Ill be going back to through the day votes and seeing if theirs any consistancy between linkcat, MMC, and killzda.
Linkcat has been constantly trying to sway the day votes each time, and I really don't believe in his far fetched reason for lynching someone. Thats typically something that would make me suspicious of the person enough to use my role on them or whatever, but not preach to the public to lynch someone for it. If thats how linkcat is gonna be basing his lynch votes, then he'll be too easily manipulated by the smallest of things a mafioso could say to him, making him more detrimental to town then to mafia in the long run while the mafia try to decieve us into thinking linkcat is doing good for town.

TL;DR Linkcats reasoning to lynch someone is so weak that it makes him a perfect target for mafia to manipulate, which is really detrimental to town.

[eljoemo]

Linkcat's move looks more scummy than it is. I mean, assuming that Nae is the only person here who would pick that name and that Linkcat knew that beforehand, then that's a really clever play, and totally in regulation with the rules. I'm not saying that he's right or that we should lynch Nae or anything; I'm just saying he might have a point if he's right.

[Solaris]

As per the request of Nae, I'm going to post a scenario, and you guys tell me if it's lynch worthy.

I received a PM a couple of days ago, names withheld for reasons. I didn't answer it. However, someone NOT on the send list responded, meaning that they were Blind Carbon Copied in it, and they were not mentioned in the PM. Would you guys be for or against lynching the person who was not mentioned, yet replied?

[Naesala]

That's really vague, and since PMs can't be quoted...it'd kind of depend on the content of the message and why the sender was sending it, who they turned out to be, etc. But thanks for posting something. Can you give any more?

[Solaris]

I'm not comfortable releasing more details at this time, just asking what you guy would do in this sotuation. I can reveal more details later.

[RavingRabbid]

Naesala (3) - Linkcat, MeowMeowCat, killsdazombies
Linkcat (1) - Naesala
iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid

temporary placeholder vote.

also, I have a feeling he's kakashihatakeswag.