Elements Mafia 51 - by Submachine

[RavingRabbid]

My logic is bulletproof

And so are zombies.

[theelkspeaks]

iancudorinmarian (2) - RavingRabbid, dawn to dusk
eljoemo (1) -mathman101
Espithel (1) - eljoemo
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (9) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, Zawadx, MeowMeowCat, savvy14112, Ginyu, UTAlan, AD TienzuStorm
Linkcat (1) - qwerter
killsdazombies (1) - Kuroaitou
Kuroaitou (2) - rob77dp, Killsdazombies
JonathanCrazyJ (1) - theelkspeaks

Mafia wouldn't be able to fake claim Herbalist this mafia because they did last time and failed, except that means we assume anyone who claims it must be town, which in turn means that they can do it safely.  JCJ could be trying to set us up to miss a play like that.

[Linkcat]

I'm willing to give Gino the benefit of the doubt. Mafia won't be so dumb as to fakeclaim Herbalist to save their asses.

You say that. They did that literally last game (though not quite so publicly)

Wow, really? You'd have to be really gullible to believe that.

[rob77dp]

iancudorinmarian (2) - RavingRabbid, dawn to dusk
eljoemo (1) -mathman101
Espithel (1) - eljoemo
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (9) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, Zawadx, MeowMeowCat, savvy14112, Ginyu, UTAlan, AD TienzuStorm
Linkcat (1) - qwerter
killsdazombies (1) - Kuroaitou
Kuroaitou (1) - killsdazombies
JonathanCrazyJ (1) - theelkspeaks

I have very good reason not to lynch Gino.  It has nothing to with Link or vote patterns or anything so vague.  Well, not vague as in it is concrete to me but will remain secret to the public.
 

I chose Kuro by a verifiable random method - chat die roll of 1d27.  Link, qwert, Kuro, Gino, dawn, maybe others can confirm this die roll ended on 4 = Kuro... so if early game no-info random is your kind of gig (verifiable random... qwert-cough-qwert!), then here ya go?

Instead of that, how about a suggested plan for town? Poke thy holes and provide thy input now fellow Villagers!

1. Do not lynch Gino- town needs a confirmed Herbalist alive.  I was given Herbs last game-night and Gino knew this information which only the target and targeter would know.

1a. Also, do not random-lynch Kuro... yet.  I did randomize to his number on chat dice but random is not as good for town as a plan.  Popular players, as I perceive Kuro to be, probably received more Mayor votes.  We don't want to risk random-lynching the Mayor already.

2. Tailor - please Disguise Linkcat and Gino tonight (Shadow Wolf protection).

3. A small band of Villagers is working a few things - don't ignore important-looking communications in-game/topic/Inbox.

4. We need a new lynch target now... and I do not have any additional ideas here for a possible target.  Villagers, let's get logical and come up with a good way to get a decent-level suspect for lynching.

[Solaris]

iancudorinmarian (2) - RavingRabbid, dawn to dusk
eljoemo (1) -mathman101
Espithel (1) - eljoemo
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (8) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, Zawadx, savvy14112, Ginyu, UTAlan, AD TienzuStorm
Linkcat (1) - qwerter
killsdazombies (1) - Kuroaitou
Kuroaitou (1) - killsdazombies
JonathanCrazyJ (1) - theelkspeaks
MeowMeowCat (1) - MeowMeowCat

Rolled 1d27 in chat, rolled 12, that's me. OBEY RNG. (Changed vote because lynching GINO is bad for town.)

[rob77dp]

iancudorinmarian (2) - RavingRabbid, dawn to dusk
eljoemo (1) -mathman101
Espithel (1) - eljoemo
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (8 ) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, Zawadx, savvy14112, Ginyu, UTAlan, AD TienzuStorm
Linkcat (1) - qwerter
killsdazombies (1) - Kuroaitou
Kuroaitou (1) - killsdazombies
JonathanCrazyJ (1) - theelkspeaks
MeowMeowCat (1) - MeowMeowCat

*Fixed the "8" problem and also adding a note here that my vote is absent on purpose -- I'll figure it out later after some info may flow here.

[rob77dp]

iancudorinmarian (2) - RavingRabbid, dawn to dusk
eljoemo (1) -mathman101
Espithel (1) - eljoemo
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (8 ) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, Zawadx, savvy14112, Ginyu, UTAlan, AD TienzuStorm
Linkcat (2) - qwerter, rob77dp
killsdazombies (1) - Kuroaitou
Kuroaitou (1) - killsdazombies
JonathanCrazyJ (1) - theelkspeaks
MeowMeowCat (1) - MeowMeowCat

Instead of that, how about a suggested plan for town? Poke thy holes and provide thy input now fellow Villagers!

1. Do not lynch Gino- town needs a confirmed Herbalist alive.  I was given Herbs last game-night and Gino knew this information which only the target and targeter would know.

1a. Also, do not random-lynch Kuro... yet.  I did randomize to his number on chat dice but random is not as good for town as a plan.  Popular players, as I perceive Kuro to be, probably received more Mayor votes.  We don't want to risk random-lynching the Mayor already.

2. Tailor - please Disguise Linkcat and Gino tonight (Shadow Wolf protection).

3. A small band of Villagers is working a few things - don't ignore important-looking communications in-game/topic/Inbox.

4. We need a new lynch target now... and I do not have any additional ideas here for a possible target.  Villagers, let's get logical and come up with a good way to get a decent-level suspect for lynching. See below...

Alright, he is my supporting argument for my vote here to lynch Linkcat:

Grasping a bit at straws, but forcing a public claim is something a good Villager should have done better to avoid (in this mafia meta, especially). Asking for a claim of a Villager-guaranteed role (herbalist) is borderline as well.

[rob77dp]

EBWOP

*Alright, here is my

[Naesala]

iancudorinmarian (2) - RavingRabbid, dawn to dusk
eljoemo (1) -mathman101
Espithel (1) - eljoemo
RavingRabbid (4) - iancudorinmarian, Discord,  Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (8 ) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, Zawadx, savvy14112, Ginyu, UTAlan, AD TienzuStorm
Linkcat (3) - qwerter, rob77dp, Naesala
killsdazombies (1) - Kuroaitou
Kuroaitou (1) - killsdazombies
JonathanCrazyJ (1) - theelkspeaks
MeowMeowCat (1) - MeowMeowCat

[Linkcat]

In no way, shape, or form did I ever communicate to Gino that he should give even a hint of his role to anybody.  Your reason for lynching me is completely false. Please confirm this with him. If he disagrees, I can show him the chat logs.

[DoubleCapitals]

If you are the Herbalist, please message me, or we will take the lynch off of Gino.

Do not make a public counterclaim.
Do not tell me you are the Herbalist if you are not the Herbalist.
If there are suggestions for a different lynch target, now is the time.

I didn't say that. I was referring to this. At this rate Gino be ded tho

[Linkcat]

My post was directed toward rob.