Elements Mafia 51 - by Submachine

[godisnowonline]

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (5) - Espithel, killsdazombies, UTAlan, MeowMeowCat, Ginyu
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
rob77dp (1) - rob77dp
Godisnowonline (2) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj

I have a good reason to vote on RavingRabbid now. The reason for this is simple. If eljoe is a werewolf, he will not be lynched and raving will be lynched instead. If we pick the person we suspect of being a werewolf and vote on them first and then start a train on a second person so that they have the same number of votes we can actually start searching for the mafia twice as fast. So lets start actually searching rather than calling someone scum because they changed their vote. If raving gets lynched and not eljoe we know eljoe is a werewolf

[Espithel]

I feel there is an issue.

Both of his votes have been super scummy.

UTAlan (2) - CrockettRocket, skyironsword
No Vote/No Lynch (12) - MeowMeowCat, jonathancrazyj, Discord, qwerter, Ginyu, iancudorinmarian, rob77dp, AD TienzuStorm, Kuroaitou, RavingRabbid, worldwideweb3, savvy14112, Coffeeditto

This was the last vote on day 1.
Where, exactly, was his vote on the previous day? You claim god has done two, but there's only been one vote, which can definitely fit a mafioso trying to stay low. (That can be said for so many votes though.)

That said, even I can see the problem in your logic, there, God:

If the vote is tied between a Human and a Werewolf, the Human gets lynched. If the vote is tied between multiple players with the same lynch priority, one of the those players will be lynched randomly.

What if both of them (eljo/RR) are civilians?
And on the silly chance that it happens, what if both of them are werewolves?
My point is that one of them dying does not confirm the other.

[killsdazombies]

I think link was referring to when his vote was changed, along with "choo choo" and "turn this train around"


also, god, its random between humans, so even if raving is killed, eljoe still might be human

[Espithel]

I think link was referring to when his vote was changed, along with "choo choo" and "turn this train around"

This is probably true; I must've misinterpretated. My apologies.
Consider me persuaded, then.

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (4) - killsdazombies, UTAlan, MeowMeowCat, Ginyu
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
rob77dp (1) - rob77dp
Godisnowonline (3) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel

[godisnowonline]

It is random if they don't have different voting priorities. It was simply a thought, i actually went back to re-read the voting priorities. As for my choochoo jokes, to put it simply i have no reason not to go with a train. What do we know already that actually makes anyone else but me look like scum?

Nothing. So all we have been doing is random lynches or lynches based off of feelings or bitterness. So lets start figuring things out. My best guess at looking is to try and see what happens with a lynch between two players. It doesn't mean they are confirmed. I thought the first player voted on gets the lynch. Anyways if people want to start testing me for scum fine.

If you pay attention each vote last mafia i almost exclusively followed the train. That didn't mean i was scum then nor does it now.

[killsdazombies]

I have literally 0 opinion on the god vote thing esp, vote how you want, I was just trying to clarify

[Linkcat]

You have not been going with trains, you have been trying to start them.

Anyways if people want to start testing me for scum fine.

Thanks, we're going to test you for scum by lynching you.

[godisnowonline]

I didn't start them. The trains each had 3 votes when i hopped around. Besides. Espithel always got lynched round one or two along with Skyironsword. Who am i to mess with tradition

[rob77dp]

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (4) - killsdazombies, UTAlan, MeowMeowCat, Ginyu
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (4) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, rob77dp

* rob77dp bids for Gino onto War team

* rob77dp votes to lynch Gino in Mafia because of train hopping?  oh, wait - it could be to give 'em more time to focus on War stuff too...

[Zawadx]

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (4) - killsdazombies, UTAlan, MeowMeowCat, Ginyu
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (5) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, rob77dp, Zawadx

[Linkcat]

What do we know already that actually makes anyone else but me look like scum?

Nothing.

I find this hilarious, because this is the exact reason we are lynching you.

Gino, let me spell this out for you and any newer players who don't see what I'm saying.

Spoiler for Explanation:

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (1) - Espithel
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (1) - iancudorinmarian

Here we have an even spread of votes. It's early, any of the 26 players could be lynched.

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (1) - Espithel
Espithel (3) - eljoemo, qwerter, Godisnowonline
RavingRabbid (1) - iancudorinmarian

Chooo Choo!

Here we see you try to start a train by putting Espithel two votes above the rest.

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (3) - Espithel, killsdazombies, UTAlan
Espithel (3) - eljoemo, qwerter, Godisnowonline
RavingRabbid (1) - iancudorinmarian

Here the vote is fairly even again. Espithel and eljoemo are a little ahead, but any player could still be lynched.

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (4) - Espithel, killsdazombies, UTAlan, Godisnowonline
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (1) - iancudorinmarian

Turn this train around

Here we see you attempt to start another train to mindlessly lynch eljoemo by putting him 2 votes ahead of the rest. This is also counterproductive to your stated goal of creating a tie.

I'd say you have at least a 60% chance of being mafia.

Ignoring the votes that have no hint of a reason behind them, this is how we stand:
iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
Espithel (1) -  qwerter
RavingRabbid (1) - Naesala
Godisnowonline (5) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, rob77dp, Zawadx

[mathman101]

iancudorinmarian (1) - RavingRabbid
eljoemo (5) - killsdazombies, UTAlan, MeowMeowCat, Ginyu, mathman101
Espithel (2) - eljoemo, qwerter
RavingRabbid (5) - iancudorinmarian, Discord, Naesala, Coffeeditto, Godisnowonline
Godisnowonline (5) - Linkcat, jonathancrazyj, Espithel, rob77dp, Zawadx

Mainly as a placeholder while I go back to read what I missed while at work today......and because I enjoy the 3-way tie