Elements Mafia 51 - by Submachine

[kirbylover314]

The greatest plot twist, Discord was human

[Zyardran]

WOOOOWWWW
gg

[Kuroaitou]

So yeah... I was Painweaver.  The other Pyromaniac.

Long story short, I thought I was doing a decent job at trying to find who was who by pretending to use the public message (while also trying to rack up 'gifts' from the merchants to improve my own special abilities), but due to Moonwolf's curse, having 'Bard' (which means even if I didn't vote, the next vote would still be stacked against me as I would be required to vote to avoid modkill and the person that I voted on would automatically be swapped) was actually a downfall. Gravedigger came too late, and because I couldn't get Shepard, I failed once more.

Sorry about all the 'WHO'S PAINWEAVER' messages and requests for the silly 'decryption' I put you guys through. It was a good run, but I failed to see who were the wolves, down to the very end (basically).

[Submachine]

Player Roles:

Spoiler for Hidden:

The werewolves were (in order of death):

• qwerter: Witness Moonwolf
• Naesala: Undertaker
• theelkspeaks: Bard
• Ginyu: Shepherd
• worldwideweb3: Town Crier

Only worldwideweb3 survived.
Kuroaitou was inflicted by the Moonwolf's Curse after qwerter died.

	Player name	Primary	Secondary	Tertiary	Phase	Method
1	skyironsword	Human	Witch Doctor		Night 1	Wolfbite
2	godisnowonline	Human	Herbalist		Chapter 2	Daykill
3	JonathanCrazyJ	Human	Courtesan		Night 2	Wolfbite
4	qwerter	Werewolf	Witness	Moonwolf	Chapter 3	Daykill
5	rob77dp	Human	Undertaker		Night 3	Wolfbite
6	Zawadx	Human	Trapmaker	Mayor	Night 3	Shadow Wolf
7	Linkcat	Human	Trapmaker		Chapter 4	Daykill
8	AD TienzuStorm	Human	Pyromaniac		Night 4	Wolfbite
9	UTAlan	Human	Witness		Night 4	Shadow Wolf
10	Naesala	Werewolf	Undertaker		Chapter 5	Daykill
11	killsdazombies	Human	Witness		Night 5	Wolfbite
12	iancudorinmarian	Human	Courtesan		Chapter 6	Daykill
13	Coffeeditto	Human	Town Guard		Night 6	Wolfbite
14	savvy14112	Human	Witch Doctor	Courtesan	Chapter 7	Daykill
15	Physsion	Human	Merchant	Witch Doctor Mayor	Chapter 7	Modkill
16	theelkspeaks	Werewolf	Bard		Chapter 7	Modkill
17	MeowMeowCat	Human	Noble		Night 7	Wolfbite
18	CrockettRocket	Human	Noble		Night 7	Shadow Wolf
19	Espithel	Human	Tailor		Night 8	Wolfbite
20	Ginyu	Werewolf	Shepherd		Chapter 9	Daykill
21	RavingRabbid	Human	Town Guard		Night 9	Shadow Wolf
22	dawn to dusk	Human	Bard		Chapter 10	Daykill
23	eljoemo	Human	Merchant	Town Crier	Night 10	Wolfbite
24	mathman101	Human	Town Crier		Chapter 11	Daykill
25	Kuroaitou	Human	Pyromaniac	Bard Mayor Undertaker Town Crier	Night 11	Wolfbite
26	Discord	Human	Shepherd		Chapter 12	Endgamed
27	worldwideweb3	Werewolf	Town Crier		Chapter 12	ALIVE!

Revealing voting tallies:

Spoiler for Hidden:

Spoiler for Chapter 4:

http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-games/elements-mafia-51-by-submachine/msg1206039/#msg1206039

Naesala (2 --> 3) - Linkcat[1],  killsdazombies[1], (Kuroaitou)[1]
Linkcat (3) - CrockettRockett[1], Naesala[1], Ginyu[1]
RavingRabbid (1 --> 0) - Kuroaitou[0](cursed)

Spoiler for Chapter 6:

http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-games/elements-mafia-51-by-submachine/msg1207111/#msg1207111

iancudorinmarian (4 --> 7) - iancudorinmarian[0], Espithel[1], Ginyu[1], CR[1], (Kuro)[4]
Ginyu (4 --> 6) - RavingRabbid[1], eljoemo[2], dawn2dusk[3], Kuro[0](cursed)
dawn (2) - MMC[1], Discord[1]

Spoiler for Chapter 10:

http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-games/elements-mafia-51-by-submachine/msg1209507/#msg1209507

Discord (4 --> 3) - dawn to dusk[0](illusion), Kuroaitou[0](cursed), eljoemo[2], worldwideweb3[1]
dawn to dusk (1 --> 3,5) - Discord[1], (Kuro)[2,5]

Spoiler for Chapter 11:

http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-games/elements-mafia-51-by-submachine/msg1209838/#msg1209838

Discord (3 --> 2) - worldwideweb3[1], Kuroaitou[0](cursed), mathman101[1]
mathman101[randomized] (0 --> 2) - (Kuro)[2]

Initial nicknames and Mayor votes (embedded in a spreadsheet):

Spoiler for Hidden:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0Bw_btfedWy30UGUwemlHTGdnRTA/view?usp=sharing
Fun fact: someone voted on RootRanger to become a Mayor.

Memorable ability uses:

Spoiler for Hidden:

• During Night 2, Zawadx attempted to use Reputation on rob77dp, but Espithel also used Disguise on rob77dp and qwerter, redirecting the investigation to qwerter.
• After Chapter 3, qwerter decided to use the Moonwolf's Curse on Kuroaitou, who had only 1 voting power. Kuro only received Bard later from eljoemo, making ~4 voting power fly around randomly.
• During Night 3, Naesala used Grave Digging on JonathanCrazyJ to use Seduce on Zawadx to target Zawadx. Then when UTAlan attempted to use Follow on Zawadx (to see who targets him by the Shadow Wolf, but he probably confused it with Hide), UTAlan got trapped, not only failing with the investigation, but also made the wolves realize that UTA is a Witness.
• During Night 4, after MeowMeowCat cracked the code of Painweaver, he figured out that the Merchant will attempt to Sell to Kuroaitou, but then he forgot and decided to use Invite on Kuroaitou instead of dawn to dusk, as opposed to Painweaver's plan.

Voting powers:

Spoiler for Hidden:

Chapter 1: no vote. (doesn't count)
Chapter 2: Illusions.
Chapter 3: votes on qwerter. (-0,5 for dawn and elk)
Chapter 4: no vote.
Chapter 5: votes on Naesala. (-0,5 for dawn and elk)
Night 5: eljoe Sells to Kuro. (+1 for eljoe)
Chapter 6: Kuro on Ginyu --> ian, elk no vote, dawn on Ginyu. (-0,5 for Kuro and dawn)
Chapter 7: no vote. Elk died with 3 voting power.
Chapter 8: votes on Ginyu. (-0,5 for Kuro and dawn)
Chapter 9: votes on Ginyu. (-0,5 for Kuro and dawn)
Chapter 10: dawn votes Illusion, Kuro on Discord. Dawn died with 1,5 voting power. (-0,5 for Kuro)
Night 10: eljoe Sells to Kuro. (+1 to eljoe)
Chapter 11: Kuro on Discord --> math. (-0,5 for Kuro)

Final voting powers:
elk:  3
dawn: 1,5
eljo: 3
Kuro: 1,5

Test game:

Spoiler for Hidden:

Before the game started, I randomized a test game when there were only 23 people in the signup list. It went like this:

Zawadx - Town Crier
worldwideweb3 - Werewolf - Pyromaniac
dawn to dusk - Witness
Kuroaitou - Werewolf - Witness
skyironsword - Trapmaker
UTAlan - Werewolf - Pyromaniac
qwerter - Courtesan
JonathanCrazyJ - Undertaker
theelkspeaks - Merchant
iancudorinmarian - Merchant
Naesala - Witness
MeowMeowCat - Witch Doctor
Espithel - Town Guard
Ginyu - Noble
Discord - Werewolf - Moonwolf - Courtesan
Linkcat - Noble
CrockettRocket - Town Crier
godisnowonline - Shepherd
mathman101 - Werewolf - Shepherd
eljoemo - Herbalist
Coffeeditto - Tailor
AD TienzuStorm - Pyromaniac
killsdazombies - Bard

Funnily enough, www3 was a werewolf in both the test and the real game. One Shepherd also became a wolf in both cases.

[Ginyu]

This mafia was a lot of fun. Thanks to Submachine for planning and hosting this event!
One of my favor factors were the Town Crier messages, that made strategizing well possible. (Fun fact: All three Criers managed to survive until short before the end. ^^)
+rep

[UTAlan]

Zawadx: Why have me target you and then set a trap? It just gave the wolves a free kill.

[worldwideweb3]

Oh boy, Mafia in the test game and the real one. Hope it doesn't come to haunt me in next game. Also, woohoo, 1st Mafia, 1st win.

[Ginyu]

So, my fellow wolf mates, time to have a party and torture what remains from those human bodies.
Our plans worked out well, even with some unlovely happenings, but that made it exciting until the end.

[Zawadx]

Zawadx: Why have me target you and then set a trap? It just gave the wolves a free kill.

Targetted link, had no idea Mafia'd be capable of redirect. I'd hoped it'd be shadow vvolf on me and vvolfbite on Link, in that case there'd be party time all around. Sometimes every single one of your ability uses is blocked tho :/

[Submachine]

UTAlan, Zawadx:

During Night 3, Naesala used Grave Digging on JonathanCrazyJ to use Seduce on Zawadx to target Zawadx. Then when UTAlan attempted to use Follow on Zawadx (to see who targets him by the Shadow Wolf, but he probably confused it with Hide), UTAlan got trapped, not only failing with the investigation, but also made the wolves realize that UTA is a Witness.

Found in the spoiler called 'Memorable ability uses'.

[Solaris]

GG wolves, and hooray for another MMC misplay, a-la Mafia 50

[Naesala]

Now I get to eat you all, yay!