Elements Mafia 49 - by ddevans96

[Christopaz]

savvy14112 (7) - iancudorinmarian, jonathancrazyj, Coffeeditto, CrockettRocket, mathman101, Godisnowonline, Linkcat
CrockettRocket (7) - MeowMeowCat, kirbylover314, Dm, eljoemo, qwerter, Zawadx, Christopaz
iancudorinmarian (5) - Zblader, Physsion, rob77dp, dawn to dusk, savvy14112
UTAlan (1) - UTAlan

My vote stands.

[Treldon]

Where did Root say he was contacted by a journalist?

I seem to remember reading so, but I just can't find a post about it. Perhaps he did so in chat?

[ZephyrPhantom]

@ ian - I find it rather odd how a random vote suddenly turned into a bandwagon like that. I could be wrong, but something about the savvy train in general just strikes me as off, and I think it needs to be investigated somehow.

[Zawadx]

I believe that elk was the Journalist that contacted Root, and Root killed elk.

Assassination > Agent > Sniper/Journalist/Priest/Matchmaker/Traveler

So nope.

Fact - Root did not kill zombie-elk.

Role priority is only the order actions are processed - one players actions do not nullify another's. It is completely possible for Root to have been the one to kill elk.

So Root died and then he killed elk? Makes no sense to me at all. Unless Root was a zombie, then my hunch on him was right all along /shifty

[DoubleCapitals]

@dd does Assassination nullify Priest's actions? I mena if you're dead you can't do stuff, and I ran it that way in my game.

[Zawadx]

Zawadx-

Suspicions can come in many forms.  It seems suspicious to me that after a few votes come in on iancu in quick succession that you are here pushing so hard to lynch an equally not-for-certain target (CR). 

Because CR is inactive and is of no value to town. ian is of some value to town, but then again he might be of negative value. As I read it there's about 50% chance for his value to be negative (aka he is gov't), but there is a certain risk in lynching him. It basically translates to whether he's journalist, or whether he's gov't trying to save his butt. But we do have a certain risk in losing our last journalist, so I'm inclined to take the safe lynch.

I also feel the quick votes on ian were mostly people jumping off the savvy wagon or trying to equalize the votes... which might merit some looking into. But most of it just seems to follow mob mentality. Like, really.

[savvy14112]

savvy14112 (7) - iancudorinmarian, jonathancrazyj, Coffeeditto, CrockettRocket, mathman101, Godisnowonline, Linkcat
CrockettRocket (8) - MeowMeowCat, kirbylover314, Dm, eljoemo, qwerter, Zawadx, Christopaz, savvy14112
iancudorinmarian (4) - Zblader, Physsion, rob77dp, dawn to dusk,
UTAlan (1) - UTAlan

[Dm]

savvy14112 (8) - iancudorinmarian, jonathancrazyj, Coffeeditto, CrockettRocket, mathman101, Godisnowonline, Linkcat,  Dm
CrockettRocket (7) - MeowMeowCat, kirbylover314, eljoemo, qwerter, Zawadx, Christopaz, savvy14112
iancudorinmarian (4) - Zblader, Physsion, rob77dp, dawn to dusk,
UTAlan (1) - UTAlan


No can do, trying to save yourself like that~

[savvy14112]

savvy14112 (8) - iancudorinmarian, jonathancrazyj, Coffeeditto, CrockettRocket, mathman101, Godisnowonline, Linkcat,  Dm
CrockettRocket (7) - MeowMeowCat, kirbylover314, eljoemo, qwerter, Zawadx, Christopaz, savvy14112
iancudorinmarian (4) - Zblader, Physsion, rob77dp, dawn to dusk,
UTAlan (1) - UTAlan


No can do, trying to save yourself like that~

Rude.

[Physsion]

savvy14112 (8 ) - iancudorinmarian, jonathancrazyj, Coffeeditto, CrockettRocket, mathman101, Godisnowonline, Linkcat, Dm
CrockettRocket (8 ) - MeowMeowCat, kirbylover314, eljoemo, qwerter, Zawadx, Christopaz, savvy14112, Physsion
iancudorinmarian (4) - Zblader, rob77dp, dawn to dusk
UTAlan (1) - UTAlan

[ZephyrPhantom]

Sigh. Given the lack of a defense, I suppose ian's logic could also be tested this way.


savvy14112 (9) - iancudorinmarian, jonathancrazyj, Coffeeditto, CrockettRocket, mathman101, Godisnowonline, Linkcat, Dm, Zblader
CrockettRocket (8 ) - MeowMeowCat, kirbylover314, eljoemo, qwerter, Zawadx, Christopaz, savvy14112, Physsion
iancudorinmarian (2) - rob77dp, dawn to dusk
UTAlan (1) - UTAlan

[rob77dp]

Sigh. Given the lack of a defense, I suppose ian's logic could also be tested this way.

Any way you can explain/support this?