Elements Mafia 47 - by skyironsword

[DoubleCapitals]

Spoiler for For reference:

Voted D1:
4. ddevans96
7. Coffeeditto
8. agdhar
10. Physsion
11. dawn to dusk
19. gusxz
20. Frozengaia
21. Terroking
Abstained D1:
3. UTAlan
5. jonathancrazyj
6. Treldon
9. mathman101
13. qwerter
14. eljoemo
15. theelkspeaks
16. Linkcat
18. Zblader
22. Opsinis

Mafia are going to gradually whittle down the people on the above list, so if anyone from that list has anything useful just out it. No need to claim. We already know Kuro was Edgeworth hence if he had anything useful now would be the time to do so. Or maybe not. I'm not sure. We can't just 'wait for Blackquill', unless you guys want another round of voting/abstaining? If we do that those who voted D1 should continue to do so because it is kind of pointless b/c mafia already knows you ain't Apollo. Also conga line might not be the best way to go about doing it considering Kristoph Gavin is around, but eh.

Anyway apart from that: With Dahlia dead, all '2U' roles can be cleared by Phoenix (though that would leave the judge, actually), and Godot, fire away with the coffee.

Now, my theory from yesterday:

Still trying to figure out how this mafia's working.  Worst vote so far looks like Kuro's, so my vote's on him.

I do not buy this. Knowing that he's an experienced player and that the rules here were rather straightforward.

theelkspeaks (1) - qwerter

[Espithel]

In the mean time, I have a theorem.

Mafia teams around here tend not to do wildly different things - Usually, they'll all do something, or they'll all not do something.

So, if Skotadi didn't vote on day one, and was modkilled day 2...
I believe the mafia might be hiding in the list of people who didn't vote day 1.

Of course, those people were coving for blackquill, and Skotadi has been an inactive noob, so... This is not the strongest of leads. At all.

Another lead is Theelk voted on Kuro and Kuro is now dead.
My opinion on that is that's the mafia trying to get us to lynch Theelk.

So, those are your things to discuss today, civilians.
Discuss them.
And if anyone has anything else to say, say it.

Pre-post-edit:
Thanks for ninjaing me, qwerter.
Now, how do "already" we know Kuro was edgeworth?

[Physsion]

Now, how do "already" we know Kuro was edgeworth?

Umm...

Kuroaitou was murdered. He was Miles Edgeworth.

theelkspeaks (1) - qwerter
Physsion (1) - Physsion

Will change this later, just making sure I don't get modkilled this round.

[ddevans96]

theelkspeaks (1) - qwerter
Physsion (1) - Physsion
mathman101 (1) - ddevans96

Hunch based on:

Another lead is Theelk voted on Kuro and Kuro is now dead.
My opinion on that is that's the mafia trying to get us to lynch Theelk.

I think mafia would have to have one experienced player to do this - looking over the list, four players stood out to me. Terro just got back, so I don't want to lynch him, I'm giving qwerter the benefit of the doubt due to him heading the strategy, and I'm not lynching myself, so that leaves math

Very loose strings, I know, I just want to provoke discussion.

[ZephyrPhantom]

My 2 cents in the form of a 1-question RQS: We have several investigative roles here, minus Edgeworth. Who would you want the remaining players with these roles to investigate?

[Espithel]

Now, how do "already" we know Kuro was edgeworth?

Umm...

Kuroaitou was murdered. He was Miles Edgeworth.

We already know Kuro was Edgeworth hence if he had anything useful now would be the time to do so.

This implies qwerter already knew Kuro was Edgeworth, before he died.

[Espithel]

EBWOP:



Learn to read the chat before posting, me

My apologies.

[gusxz]

I supose the mafia are in the group that abstained in D1. But as qwerter showed, we have 10 vote options...
It would be nice if Apollo could randomly vote (vote twice in a raw to change the group of people he affects) so that he might effect a mafia voting.
We should mix again the people so that no one knows whether he would effect D3 or D4.


I guess it would make sense to split the vote in at least 2 or 3 people.
Kristoph Gavin can add 2 to the voting total and they should aim for the ones that voted in D1. If we lynched Daryan Crescent for exemple, the second place might be decided by Kristoph.
If we follow the pattern, mafia would't vote now. But I guess they could try to lynch a mafia member they might try to change the balance if the "candidates" are just 1 or 2 votes apart.

theelkspeaks (1) - qwerter
Physsion (1) - Physsion
mathman101 (1) - ddevans96
eljoemo (1) - gusxz

[Espithel]

I supose the mafia are in the group that abstained in D1. But as qwerter showed, we have 10 vote options...
It would be nice if Apollo could randomly vote (vote twice in a raw to change the group of people he affects) so that he might effect a mafia voting.
We should mix again the people so that no one knows whether he would effect D3 or D4.


I guess it would make sense to split the vote in at least 2 or 3 people.
Kristoph Gavin can add 2 to the voting total and they should aim for the ones that voted in D1. If we lynched Daryan Crescent for exemple, the second place might be decided by Kristoph.
If we follow the pattern, mafia would't vote now. But I guess they could try to lynch a mafia member they might try to change the balance if the "candidates" are just 1 or 2 votes apart.

theelkspeaks (1) - qwerter
Physsion (1) - Physsion
mathman101 (1) - ddevans96
eljoemo (1) - gusxz

Don't edit your posts.
If you want to change your post, make a new post and do all your changes there.
This is to make sure people don't change what they say and important info isn't erased willy-nilly.

Anyway, everything here seems pretty reasonable. Yeah, be chaotic, blackquill.
Good catch there.

[DoubleCapitals]

My 2 cents in the form of a 1-question RQS: We have several investigative roles here, minus Edgeworth. Who would you want the remaining players with these roles to investigate?

Phoenix: Target the unconfirmed. '2U' roles are confirmed townies.
Trucy: Target the unconfirmed. As to when I have honestly no idea, but when you do it, claim since you're practically a VT once you done it. And state your target if nothing happens because well that person's probably inno. Definitely inno, sorry.
Athena: If Apollo plans to abstain today, target the unconfirmed.
Ema/Dick: Target the same... person I guess. Maybe we could do something like what CR did. I need to reread those.

I assume some of these roles must have already confirmed themselves.

[dawn to dusk]

theelkspeaks (1) - qwerter
Physsion (1) - Physsion
mathman101 (1) - ddevans96
eljoemo (1) - gusxz
dawn to dusk (1) - dawn to dusk

i have a lead, pretty sure this guy is scum

maybe not but its still worth a shot

[gusxz]

Don't edit your posts.
If you want to change your post, make a new post and do all your changes there.
This is to make sure people don't change what they say and important info isn't erased willy-nilly.

Sorry about that. I forgot to vote.