Elements Mafia 47 - by skyironsword

[ZephyrPhantom]

UTAlan (3) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader

[UTAlan]

Frozen, I had no reason to trust you with my real role. I learned early on that role claims in chat don't usually end well for town. On phone now, but will post more shortly.

[dawn to dusk]

UTAlan (3) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk

until further notice

[dawn to dusk]

UTAlan (4) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk

fixed

[ddevans96]

I learned early on that role claims in chat don't usually end well for town.

Then say as much. There's nothing wrong with that, at that time you have no reason to trust him. Lying is more suspicious - see http://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Lynch_All_Liars

[DoubleCapitals]

I feel reaaaaaallllllllly uneasy about the idea of trading roles in the early game, but yet, dd is also right. Town generally do not have incentive to lie about their roles. In addition, Frozen became confirmed on D2. UTA could and should have trusted Frozen with the truth about his role.

UTAlan (5) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk, qwerter

UTA, for the sake of argument let us say you did not trust Frozen. What would you claim then?

[Espithel]

Frozen, I had no reason to trust you with my real role. I learned early on that role claims in chat don't usually end well for town. On phone now, but will post more shortly.

So why did you ask for roleclaims in the first place?

[UTAlan]

*sigh*

I'm a newb is my biggest defense. I don't want to reveal my role publicly unless absolutely necessary. It always drives me crazy when a townie just gives up and gets lynched without putting up some sort of defense for themselves, though I don't know that I can convince you guys that I'm not mafia. Note to self: don't lie as a townie or it looks really bad.

Fwiw, at least if I get lynched the number of "unconfirmed" will go down. If we don't lynch me, we should go for someone else that isn't confirmed to narrow down the possible mafia remaining.

UTAlan (5) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk, qwerter
theelkspeaks (1) - UTAlan

[DoubleCapitals]

[...]It always drives me crazy when a townie just gives up and gets lynched without putting up some sort of defense for themselves[...]

For this, I must thank you.

[Linkcat]

UTAlan (6) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk, qwerter, Linkcat
theelkspeaks (1) - UTAlan

[JonathanCrazyJ]

UTAlan (6) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk, qwerter, Linkcat, jonathancrazyj
theelkspeaks (1) - UTAlan

Guess it's all we have to go on for now

[JonathanCrazyJ]

EBWOP

didn't update the number of votes doh

UTAlan (7) - ddevans96, Frozengaia, Zblader, dawn to dusk, qwerter, Linkcat, jonathancrazyj
theelkspeaks (1) - UTAlan