Elements Mafia 46 - by Frozengaia

[kirbylover314]

skyironsword (2) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314
theelkspeaks (2) - Zblader, Zawadx
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (3) - UTAlan, ddevans96, flyingcat

RNJesus told me to vote on sky. Too many possibilities anyways >_<

[kirbylover314]

skyironsword (3) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314
theelkspeaks (2) - Zblader, Zawadx
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (3) - UTAlan, ddevans96, flyingcat

Fixed count

[skyironsword]

skyironsword (3) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314
theelkspeaks (2) - Zblader, Zawadx
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (4) - UTAlan, ddevans96, flyingcat, skyironsword

[ZephyrPhantom]

skyironsword (3) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314
theelkspeaks (1) - Zawadx
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (5) - UTAlan, ddevans96, flyingcat, skyironsword, Zblader

Alan's line of thought seems like a sound strategy to me. Starting to get a little suspicious of flyingcat with his supposed inactivity trouble, though.

[flyingcat]

*A few rereads later...*
The gist of what I'm getting is we have no idea what's going on.
1. Zawadx
2. Flyingcat Vanilla Victim
3. Treldon I dunno, seems a little too helpful with the poker hands and such. But then again, I dunno.
4. mathman101 DEAD
5. eljoemo DEAD
6. UTAlan Leaning towards civvie
7. kirbylover Being kirby and trying to survive
8. Physsion DEAD
9. iancumarindorian Somewhat fishy
10. Dawn to Dusk DEAD
11. Linkcat Inactive, probably going to die
12. Ddevans96 Confirmed Vanilla Victim
13. Zblader While he seems to be civvie, I have a feeling he's a really good mafia... or I'm just being paranoid again.
14. qwerter
15. Kuroaitou Somewhat inactive
16. Skyironsword Inactive
17. theelkspeaks

[ZephyrPhantom]

*A few rereads later...*
The gist of what I'm getting is we have no idea what's going on.
1. Zawadx
2. Flyingcat Vanilla Victim
3. Treldon I dunno, seems a little too helpful with the poker hands and such. But then again, I dunno.
4. mathman101 DEAD
5. eljoemo DEAD
6. UTAlan Leaning towards civvie
7. kirbylover Being kirby and trying to survive
8. Physsion DEAD
9. iancumarindorian Somewhat fishy
10. Dawn to Dusk DEAD
11. Linkcat Inactive, probably going to die
12. Ddevans96 Confirmed Vanilla Victim
13. Zblader While he seems to be civvie, I have a feeling he's a really good mafia... or I'm just being paranoid again.
14. qwerter
15. Kuroaitou Somewhat inactive
16. Skyironsword Inactive
17. theelkspeaks

skyironsword (1) - theelkspeaks
theelkspeaks (2) - Zblader, Zawadx
flyingcate (1) - iancudorinmarian

Voting later because he doesn't want to vote on any of these 2 people, which might be mafia. I think he waits for one of us to find another suspect to vote on him, rather than vote on his comrade or the other one to look suspicious if the one who dies is mafia.

That's all I have now.

There seems to be a bit of fudging details here. Ian, cat, care to defend yourselves?

[flyingcat]

Anyone who suspects a cat is obviously a fish because cats eat fish and fish are fishy so ian must be fishy.

Spoiler for But Seriously:

Source of quote: Day 1
I dun wanna bandwagon... yet. We should take advantage of this Day 1 thing with confirmed civilian.
skyironsword- Zblader
flyingcat- flyingcat

[iancudorinmarian]

I'm pretty sure he says I'm fishy because I voted on him. Not that my vote counts anyway now, but I'll keep it.

[Linkcat]

Sorry about not voting yesterday. I got a new cat and I was busy helping her adjust to her new home.

Sky volunteered to be confirmed after I started the dd wagon, which makes her a bit less suspicious than others. I have mild suspicions on others, but I'm appalled at how elk failed to notice this fact. So let's start with him.

I'd say that was a pretty okay gamble to take for sky as mafia - most people know dd's Master of Mafia, and having him as confirmed was the most likely result, and it buys sky free townpoints just for suggesting it (as evidenced by your post).  Not to say that it makes sky more likely to be mafia - but rather to say that anyone who volunteered to be confirmed after the wagon was already started on dd shouldn't get any special town-credit for it.

This is pretty much exactly what I was thinking. Skyironsword didn't have much chance to get lynched, so that doesn't make her more likely to be town. The same can't be said for flyingcat, as his self-vote was only the second vote, putting him more at risk.

One of the best ways for mafia to win especially on a site that behaves like this one is to try to go unnoticed.

I completely agree with this statement.

 The most inactive/unnoteworthy players, in order:

kirbylover314: No posts outside of voting/RQS.

Kuroaitou: No posts outside of voting/RQS. Had longest answers to RQS.

iancudorinmarian: Has posted outside of voting/RQS, but without promoting discussion. Only noteworthy post putting suspicion on flyingcat.

I've also been inactive, but not voting and being the only person not to answer the RQS, especially after Zblader pointed it out, was likely to draw attention to myself. I was planning on joining the discussion before anyone voted on me, but there's no way to verify that.

I'm not particularly suspicious of skyironsword, but this vote gives the highest chance of not lynching another vanilla victim, which we don't want.

skyironsword (4) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314, Linkcat
theelkspeaks (1) - Zawadx
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (5) - UTAlan, ddevans96, flyingcat, skyironsword, Zblader

Now that the main reason for lynching me is gone, can we lynch someone else?

[ddevans96]

skyironsword (4) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314, Linkcat
theelkspeaks (2) - Zawadx, ddevans96
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (4) - UTAlan, flyingcat, skyironsword, Zblader

Alright, fair enough. Personally, looking over everything, I don't see a valid case on sky. fc and elk seem considerably more suspicious to me right now.

[ZephyrPhantom]

Welp. There goes that line of thought.

skyironsword (4) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314, Linkcat
theelkspeaks (3) - Zawadx, ddevans96, Zblader
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (3) - UTAlan, flyingcat, skyironsword

Going back to my original plan. I still think something is funky with elk, based on my RQS judgements.

[Linkcat]

skyironsword (3) - theelkspeaks, qwerter, kirbylover314
theelkspeaks (4) - Zawadx, ddevans96, Zblader, Linkcat
flyingcat (1) - iancudorinmarian
Linkcat (3) - UTAlan, flyingcat, skyironsword

Trusting ddevans96 on this one.