1) Assuming you are a civilian, how would you try to win this mafia?
2) Assuming you are mafia, how would you try to win this mafia?
3) What are the three best civilian roles? Why is this?
4) What are the three worst civilian roles? Why is this?
1.) The policeman needs to build a network of confirmed civilians, which will eventually grow large enough to overcome the mafia. I don't have any twisted master plan this time around, because the rules are actually constructed properly. There's no such instant-win button for the civilians because a secondary role is not enough to determine whether one is civilian or mafia.
2.) The mafia need to find each other, fast. They would have to collectively figure out a way to all target the same person - probably whoever is taking on the role as leader of the civs. In this case, it seems like the mafia should probably all target Frozengaia. Sorry mate
3.) The most useful civilians are the Policeman, Detective, and Sociologist. It's the opposite of real life, essentially.
4.) The least useful civilians are the Politician, Astrologist, and Lawyer. Honorable mention goes to Influential. Voting roles just aren't very strong if they're capped at 2-3. They would have to be 4-5 in order to do much.