As a reminder for those who haven't been paying attention, there is a 32% chance that I am a mafioso and the policeman who targeted me is a civ. There is a 68% chance that the policeman who targeted me is a mafioso and I am a civ. I worked this out earlier and will further explain it to anyone willing to listen.
I think it would be very unwise to lynch me in order to protect someone who is most likely a mafioso.
Please, im willing to listen. I have a question though, wise master root. How disastrous, on a scale 1 to 10 ,with 10 being devastating, for the civvy's would it be to publically say whose the civvy cop, when their is a 50/50 between him being mafia or civvy? So if the town wastes a lynch by lynching one of their most needed roles, how disastrous would it be? In your RQS you practically said policemen should get a confirmed bunch and go from there. If you are civvy, and your civvy cop just died, how would you try to win the game? Id also like to hear two more things. If you are civvy, and your bodyguard just died, how would you try to win the game? If you are civvy, and your bodyguard and policemen just died, how would you try to win the game?
I'll repeat the questions that arn't rhetorical.
How disastrous, on a scale 1 to 10 ,with 10 being devastating, for the civvy's would it be to publically say whose the civvy cop, when their is a 50/50 between him being mafia or civvy?
If you are civvy, and your civvy cop just died, how would you try to win the game / what would your plan be?
If you are civvy, and your bodyguard just died, how would you try to win the game / what would your plan be?
If you are civvy, and your bodyguard and policemen just died, how would you try to win the game?
I don't think there is a reasonable answer to these questions, and these are possibilities that could happen if we follow your proposed lynching based on probabilities between town's day 2 lynch and/or mafia's N2 NK on the bodyguard.
Currently your proposed lynch instead of yourself is utter crap, and if its not, I'd like to see you prove it by answering those questions. Your plans could become a HUGE detriment to the town, and any detriment to the town is worth lynching regardless of if they're mafia or civvy. At this point, idc if you're mafia or civilian, your plans can be a huge disaster for town and thus your a detriment. Answer the 4 questions above please for everyone to analyze and judge the plans. Currently taking a random shot a cop when not knowing both the cops could be vastly dangerous to town. When it has game deciding effects like that, I ask for a safer plan.
