Honestly I dont even plan on sticking to my vote. I think townies should definitely communicate, just be less public about all their information or else mafia will know who to target. I suspect they killed Kuro, a lurker, not because hes do an amazing social game, but because he had a good role. I think you're trying to get townies to be very public about all their information. I dont want to silence townies at all. As for trying to shut you up about lurkers, its day 3 bud. People have plans to vote on specific people they fid suspicious rather than a stupid kill lurkers vote. Mafia are active people by now since this thread's been talking about lurkers the entire time. Go back to every mafia where civvies won, is there 18 frikin pages by day 3?! If so, links please. If you want, Ill provide you links for every unnumbered mafia as well.
If people have plans to vote on people they find suspicious, they should feel free to tell us them.
I plan to kill the lurkers, because lurkers are always inherently suspicious.
Is this any different?
Assuming Kuro is/was a PR, who told the mafia that?
That was never mentioned in this thread.
If the mafia did kill Kuro due to being a PR, that was told in a private conversation.
Who told the mafia that?
I don't know. We never will know, most likely. If Kuro is/was a PR, and someone told the mafia, unsuspectingly, that they were, that someone will be too ashamed to step forward and tell the truth.
And because we don't know, we're at a disadvantage.
If someone publicly told someone that Kuro was a PR... Well, who's going to do that, honestly?
Telling EVERYONE makes you do better plays and makes you less likely to do stupid things... like telling EVERYONE, thus, THE MAFIA, who someone's role is.
Then again, we could blame Kuro for telling an uncomfirmed person their role...
Someone's role is not what I'm interested in. Don't ever give that away unless you absolutely have to.
Of course, if you're being that stupid to roleclaim to others without a reason, you kinda deserve to die. Juuuuust sayin'.
And as for the 18 pages by day 3 argument, correlation does not make causation. Just because a mafia thread has less pages doesn't mean the townies suddenly win.
I haven't looked at previous mafias, but I'm pretty sure D2D got about 14 pages by day 3.
But it doesn't matter too much- the last few mafias were quite badly set up, this one seems fine...r.
-
Onto Ian, it's easy to change our votes if need be. If this time was used more effectively, we could have used this time to investigate more, and use those investigations AND your investigations.
