Elements Mafia 39 - by eljoemo

[ddevans96]

Mort (1) - qwerter
Dm1321 (1) - justaburd
SpikeSpiegel (1) - iancudorinmarian
justaburd (1) - SpikeSpiegel
No Vote (7) - RootRanger, Fippe94, Mort, dawn to dusk, skyironsword, Ungaros, ddevans96

Will answer RQS as soon as possible.

[DoubleCapitals]

1. What do you think is the best ability available in this mafia?
2. Why do you like playing mafia?
3. What is the best strategy for the town to take with their abilities?

1. Certainly the Hacker. He would reveal Admin reports while keeping the identities of the Admins secret (if used correctly!) and allow the entirety of the town to deduce results from the Admins.
2. It appeals to me, the idea that there is evil among us and we have to do our utmost to stamp them out before they get to us. Just like in real life.
3. Like so many have said before me, N1 Admins self-investigate, Hacker shouldn't do anything. N2 Admins investigate whoever they think is most scummy. D3 Admins who have conflicting reports should claim, and be protected by the helper. I think that -should- solve the problem of the admin issue should be resolved hopefully by Day 3 or 4, barring some unfortunate situation where Admins get killed N1/N2.

[DoubleCapitals]

EBWOP: The important thing is actually for Admins to claim as soon as they receive conflicting reports, so that we can narrow it down the identities of the Admins asap. This is true even if you targetted someone who got killed or lynched already. We can get Gladmin/Sadmin to claim so that they can be cleared and lead the town (I hope). I actually don't think it is necessary for Admins to target themselves N1 come to think of it, but if that is what the majority of the town is going for, then we should do so for the sake of consistency

[ddevans96]

1) Maybe not best, but I'm partial to Addict, because it's a potential confirmation rule, if I understand it correctly.
2) It's a good game to test intelligence, strategy, and cleverness.
3) I have nothing to add to strategy that hasn't already been covered. Lots of talented players here.

[ddevans96]

role*

[Aneninen]

Spike, I'll try to summarize RootRanger's plan again.

The Admins check the Veteran (instead of themselves), so the Hacker reveals their check. (Most probably the Veteran will be targetted by the Trolls but, he has a 50% chance of survival.) So, the more don't vote the harder to find out who the Hacker is.

Mort (1) - qwerter
Dm1321 (1) - justaburd
SpikeSpiegel (1) - iancudorinmarian
justaburd (1) - SpikeSpiegel
No Vote (8) - RootRanger, Fippe94, Mort, dawn to dusk, skyironsword, Ungaros, ddevans96, Aneninen

[Aneninen]

That 8) was supposed to be a number 8 in brackets. ^_^

Also, I would like to ask the PVP-er to PM me.

[Mort]

Also, I would like to ask the PVP-er to PM me.

And how exactly do we know that you're not just trolling us?

[iancudorinmarian]

Also, I would like to ask the PVP-er to PM me.

And how exactly do we know that you're not just trolling us?

Asking a civilian to PM you the first day is just too suspicious...

Mort (1) - qwerter
Dm1321 (1) - justaburd
justaburd (1) - SpikeSpiegel
Aneninen (1) -iancudorinmarian

I'm on my phone and I'm too lazy to copy all those names.

Do we really have to say we don't want vote?

[dawn to dusk]

Also, I would like to ask the PVP-er to PM me.

And how exactly do we know that you're not just trolling us?

Asking a civilian to PM you the first day is just too suspicious...

Mort (1) - qwerter
Dm1321 (1) - justaburd
justaburd (1) - SpikeSpiegel
Aneninen (1) -iancudorinmarian

I'm on my phone and I'm too lazy to copy all those names.

Do we really have to say we don't want vote?

i think its there to point it out to mafia

[Aneninen]

Also, I would like to ask the PVP-er to PM me.

And how exactly do we know that you're not just trolling us?

We've just decided a sensible plan for the first day. If I were a troll I'd try to (1) either disrupt the plan somehow (2) do nothing and avoid drawing the attention on myself and hope that someone else gets lynched.

Instead of this I've brought a new role, the PVP-er into the picture. I don't think killing the PVP-er is a top priority of the Trolls; finding the Hacker, the useful Admins or simly trolling RootRanger since it was him who had invented our plan. By eliminating the PVP-er they would have an insignificant advantage since, in the early game the PVP-er hardly knows whom he or she should target. Besides, due to the plan the Hacker is technically un-findable the Admins are totally unknown right now and RootRanger will be protected by the Helper.

So, if I were a troll I'd try to convince either an Admin or the Hacker to contact me. Instead of this I search for the PVP-er and draw the attention of myself.

But, since it seems that Mort is not the only one who started to think that I'm a Troll, it's better if the PVP-er doesn't PM me and I announce here my request: tonight the PVP-er should target ... ME !

[Aneninen]

Anyway, Mort, I've sent you a PM as well.

I repeat the voting since the No Vote list has been left out and in my version it was corrupted by that stupid smiley:

Mort (1) - qwerter
Dm1321 (1) - justaburd
justaburd (1) - SpikeSpiegel
Aneninen (1) -iancudorinmarian
No Vote (8 ) - RootRanger, Fippe94, Mort, dawn to dusk, skyironsword, Ungaros, ddevans96, Aneninen