Elements Mafia 39 - by eljoemo

[eljoemo]

I genuinely didn't expect an actual petition to go around

But in the interests of being a good and fair host, if you can get >50% of sign-ups on your cause before Sunday, I will gladly change that rule for you.

And before anyone asks why I didn't just put up a poll, its because I'm a lazy sod

[DoubleCapitals]

Personally I think the idea of cops not being revealed upon death forces cops to an extent to reveal their role (and reports); we have not seen much of claiming the past few games, just secret underground networks of cleared people, thereby offsetting the mafia disadvantage of not having power roles.

[skyironsword]

Personally I think the idea of cops not being revealed upon death forces cops to an extent to reveal their role (and reports); we have not seen much of claiming the past few games, just secret underground networks of cleared people, thereby offsetting the mafia disadvantage of not having power roles.

These words have too many syllables. Either that, or the sentence doesn't make sense.

[RootRanger]

Personally I think the idea of cops not being revealed upon death forces cops to an extent to reveal their role (and reports); we have not seen much of claiming the past few games, just secret underground networks of cleared people, thereby offsetting the mafia disadvantage of not having power roles.

These words have too many syllables. Either that, or the sentence doesn't make sense.

If the identities of the admins are not revealed when they die, then it forces the admins to play more risky. In order to be of much use, they would have to reveal their role and their reports to people who have not been confirmed to be innocent. This could make the game more interesting, instead of all the action taking place among small underground networks of people who have been proven innocent. Additionally, it disadvantages the civilians for admin identities to be undisclosed upon death; this is a fair trade because the mafia do not have any power roles.

[skyironsword]

Petition:
1) ddevans
2) qwerter
3) Ungaros
4) CrockettRocket
5) skyironsword

Oh, and eljoemo, a lot of people aren't even reading the thread. >50% may be pushing it.

[Pineapple]

Petition:
1) ddevans
2) qwerter
3) Ungaros
4) CrockettRocket
5) skyironsword
6) pineapple

For reasons already stated. Vote subject to change if other changes are implemented.

[RootRanger]

Oh, and eljoemo, a lot of people aren't even reading the thread. >50% may be pushing it.

Agreed. I'm honestly surprised there are even 6 people who care, much less agree that sanity should not be revealed on death. Compare this to the number in opposition, which is drastically lower, and I would make the rule change official.

[eljoemo]

Oh, and eljoemo, a lot of people aren't even reading the thread. >50% may be pushing it.

Agreed. I'm honestly surprised there are even 6 people who care, much less agree that sanity should not be revealed on death. Compare this to the number in opposition, which is drastically lower, and I would make the rule change official.

m'kay, well 6 is enough I guess, its more than those appealing for the rule to stay.

OFFICIAL RULE CHANGE: Admin deaths will be declared simply as "An Admin"; sanity will no longer be revealed publicly.

inb4, 6 more people start a petition to change the rule back

[dawn to dusk]

I personally dislike that, however, that may be because I didn't play my own mafia ^^

[Ungaros]

I'd like to start a petition to make mafia not be able to nightkill. After all, isn't the town doing enough killing with the lynchings?

[iancudorinmarian]

I'd like to start a petition to make mafia not be able to nightkill. After all, isn't the town doing enough killing with the lynchings?

I don't agree with that, that's the whole fun being a mafia, nightkilling, plotting horrible crimes during the night, don't take away their fun! Plus, mafia doesn't have any abilities as well, that would be a sure win for town. So I'm against this. If a lot of people agree, I can't argue though.

[Fippe94]

Uh, I am *pretty* sure Ungaros was being sarcastic.