Elements Mafia 39 - by eljoemo

[Zawadx]

What's the role of the Gladadmin and the Sadadmin anyway? I could only see them useful to determine which ones are the Admin and the Badadmin. (come to think of it, that might be the general idea though)

They're useless. That's the thing. They're there to confuse everyone and make it harder to find out which investigations are correct. Dilutes the investigative power of the Admin and Badmin.

[DoubleCapitals]

What I'm more worried about are the 4 cop sanities actually; I personally think it is too much information for town to work with; how about adopting an idea from another site I know of - cop sanities not being revealed upon death? I don't know, it might sound crazy, but it encourages cops to speak up lest they get lynched/killed?

My bad. Saw in the rules cop sanities not revealed upon death. Now we're talking.

[dawn to dusk]

It's seeming very similar to my one so if you are confused, look at mine

Link: http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-game-archive/elements-mafia-37-by-dawn-to-dusk/

[iancudorinmarian]

It's seeming very similar to my one so if you are confused, look at mine

Link: http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-game-archive/elements-mafia-37-by-dawn-to-dusk/

Are the admins going to be revealed when they die? Like this:
FG kill: Mister Ghosty (Shadow)

[eljoemo]

It's seeming very similar to my one so if you are confused, look at mine

Link: http://elementscommunity.org/forum/forum-game-archive/elements-mafia-37-by-dawn-to-dusk/

Are the admins going to be revealed when they die? Like this:
FG kill: Mister Ghosty (Shadow)

That is correct; admin sanity will be revealed upon death. Unless of course you can petition me otherwise.

[ddevans96]

Petition:
1) ddevans
2) qwerter?

[DoubleCapitals]

Petition:
1) ddevans
2) qwerter

Well, hopefully.

[Ungaros]

Sanity to be not revealed upon death!
Petition:
1) ddevans
2) qwerter
3) Ungaros

[skyironsword]

I'm kind of on the fence. What's so bad about sanity being revealed on death, though?

[CrockettRocket]

Sanity to be not revealed upon death!
Petition:
1) ddevans
2) qwerter
3) Ungaros

Add me to, except if it's the first round and one of people with sanities die, then it should be revealed upon death. Let them using their ability at least once when they're pretty important.

[Kuroaitou]

I'm kind of on the fence. What's so bad about sanity being revealed on death, though?

Pro: Having sanity revealed allows civilians figure out which of the admins are the truthful/liar ones, so as to ascertain the roles of everyone else. Makes it easier for civilians to gain knowledge faster.
Con: Having sanity revealed makes it extremely hard for mafia members to stay hidden if all admins choose different target/work together to figure out what their sanity is by definition.

That being said, as a FGO, it's ultimately up to the host to decide how a role is played out in their mafia. I will remain neutral until the hosts decides/starts the game.

[RootRanger]

If they're starting a petition, can I filibuster? I've always liked the idea of pointless ranting for hours on end...

On a serious note, I'd prefer sanity be revealed on death. The hacker only reveals information once every two rounds, and the admins will have a pretty tough time finding each other. They're not going to be very useful if sanity isn't revealed on death.