So there are 3-4 mafia/13 people, so the chance of picking a mafia is getting pretty high, and the otyugh didn't devour anybody yet, so we still have a chance of winning with voting. Even if Crocket's list is not complete/fully correct, it's better than nothing.
I personally have no leads yet on who could be mafia, but I know pretty much civilians from Crocket's list. Still, you may argue that such a list is wrong and/or incomplete, but as I said, it's better than nothing. Plus, I really had faith in Crocket's strategy. Anyway, let's not start a fight again.