Elements mafia - 15 - Run by killsdazombies!

[Skydaemon]

I'm going through voting history for nilsieboy atm.  So far it looks like FG's try to have no more than 2 of them on the final kill target.

nilsieboy voting history:

round 1 (pg 8):
$$$man (kill)

Final killing vote list:
Appawesome - 2 (Hyroen, Wardead)
Dragoon1140 - 4 (Kakerlake, thenewguy, Terroking, Demagog)
$$$man - 7 (1world24, Kuroaitou, nilsieboy, RavingRabbid, Shantu, Dragoon1140)
Thenewguy - 2 (Skydaemon, majofa)
Korugar - 1(ShiningSword)
Terroking - 2 (QuantumT, patchx94)
patchx94 - 1 (AppAwesome)
1world24 - 2 (Korugar, ddevans96)
round 2 (pg 18):
1world24 (unlikely to kill - hyroen and ddevans on kill target, but not raving)

Final killing vote list:
1world24 - 7 (Kakerlake, Shantu, RavingRabbid, nilsieboy, Quantumt, Demagog, Dragoon1140)
Appawesome - 2 (thenewguy, Kuroaitou)
thenewguy - 1 (majofa)
Demagog - 9 (Korugar, 1world24, Hyroen, Terroking, Skydaemon, ShiningSword, Wardead, ddevans96, AppAwesome)
round 3 (pg 26):
-pre-virus kill, nilsieboy votes for ddevans96,
-ravingrabbid votes against nilsieboy
-ends up with no vote, after hyroen comes back from the dead to erase nilsieboy's defunct vote on terminated ddevans96 (pg 26)

Final killing vote list:
Dragoon1140 - 6 (Terroking, Kakerlake, ShiningSword, QuantumT, Shantu, majofa)
nilsieboy - 2 (RavingRabbid,1world24)
Appawesome - 1 (Skydaemon)
*nilsieboy attempted to vote against ddevans96 who got virus-killed instead, dragoon was known to be the village idiot/guardian angel
round 4 (pg 32):
nilsieboy votes against shantu

Shantu - 1 (nilsieboy)
majofa - 1 (RavingRabbid)
RavingRabbid - 6 (Kakerlake, 1world24, thenewguy, majofa,ShiningSword,Shantu,QuantumT)
QuantumT- 2 (Skydaemon, Terroking)
He looks really guilty if you ask me.

Round 1 and 2 FGs have no more than 2 on the final kill list.
Round 3 they decide to target other FGs to throw suspicion off (and because they didn't really want to kill the village idiot). - nilsieboy tried to target ddevans96 who was virus killed and it looked like nilsieboy didn't return to correct his vote.
Round 4 they target randomly, but still not on the real lynch target (who was an FG).

[1world24]

Can we please just mod-kill 7wavemaster,its 4 days and he only made sign up. ill make a kill story and just fill in the role. As 7wavemaster snuck out of his house for the first time in days since the mafia struck,1world24 shouted,"KILL HIM!".As they drag him to the cliff and push him off to his doom,they soon realize what he was.7wavemaster was the (blank/blank)

[Skydaemon]

Thinking about it further, with Raving being a witness, it makes even more sense for him to develop a plausible story for when he used his ability to save nilsieboy from lynching.  If he had a track record of stating he believed nilsieboy was innocent, that covers his ability when he actually uses it.

[Skydaemon]

I would point out that shining had asked for the doctor to protect someone else this last round, whereas I knew shining was on the protected list.  So I don't think him being protected is suspicious at all.

Raving definitely wasn't involved in picking the doctor target, and there's only 1 FG remaining, so shining targetting himself when he doesn't think he had protection doesn't make sense.

In case you're wondering why shining was protected, it was because he was the first to finger raving a couple rounds ago who turned out to be an FG.  I figured they'd try to kill him to get him off their tail, but I never mentioned that to shining.

In other words, I'm fairly confident shining is really innocent.

[Skydaemon]

Reading page 31 and looking at the momentum shift from majofa over to ravingrabbid.  I'd say that speaks in favor of shantu, majofa, and thenewguy.  They were basically responsible for a last minute momentum shift to raving which otherwise might not have happened.

There was also no attempt at defense at that point.  Possibly because nilsieboy was afk at the day end and didn't see it in time.

[ShiningSword]

YAY, power of the doc attacks again. Fg finding power attacks again(2/4 suspected from early rounds isnt bad).
But now, i think it is time to think out of the box to find the last fg.(lets just say im not lynching the primary suspect just now).

[nilsieboy]

guys, i'm innocent.
i'm civy/armagio.
didn't know rav was a fg, i searched for someone who'd help me at the start because you're stronger with 2 then alone.
he said he was civy/witness and i trusted him where i made a big mistake for wich i'm srry.
go ahead and kill me, but when you do that remember that you killed ANOTHER innocent .
nilsieboy -5 ( Skydaemon, QuantumT, Shantu. Terroking,5)
QuantumT - 1 (nilsieboy)

[ShiningSword]

guys, i'm innocent.
i'm civy/armagio.

Too bad, that one is taken(but if you really are, we might consider to lynch the other guy).

didn't know rav was a fg, i searched for someone who'd help me at the start because you're stronger with 2 then alone.
he said he was civy/witness and i trusted him where i made a big mistake for wich i'm srry.

You dont select a friend out of the game(i assume you have been atleast teammates) to be your friend in game(because you will trust him too much). Same applies the other way around.

[RavingRabbid]

Ah, I'm dead. I'm not talking.


But the $$$man kill was just pure luck, believe me.

[ShiningSword]

But the $$$man kill was just pure luck, believe me.

Yeah, we know. After all, he was seer and gambler, so there was no way for you to know that. If it was good or bad luck, thats another matter(considering how do you 3 ended, suspected by all of us, I think it was bad luck)

[nilsieboy]

guys, i'm innocent.
i'm civy/armagio.

Too bad, that one is taken(but if you really are, we might consider to lynch the other guy).

didn't know rav was a fg, i searched for someone who'd help me at the start because you're stronger with 2 then alone.
he said he was civy/witness and i trusted him where i made a big mistake for wich i'm srry.

You dont select a friend out of the game(i assume you have been atleast teammates) to be your friend in game(because you will trust him too much). Same applies the other way around.

i had mafias were i did it alone, believe me, it's better when you start with someone else (it's only crap if you find out it's a fg -,-")

[majofa]

nilsieboy -5 (Skydaemon, QuantumT, Shantu, Terroking, 1world24)
QuantumT - 1 (nilsieboy)
Skydaemon - 1 (majofa)