Elements Mafia!

[Kamietsu]

Or just make a thirteenth spot... for "other."

That was my idea, but I guess SG fixed that unless she would still like to play.

[Scaredgirl]

Or just make a thirteenth spot... for "other."

That was my idea, but I guess SG fixed that unless she would still like to play.

It's my understanding that the number of participants has to be an even number. Otherwise one team has an advantage. I can sit this one out, np.

[miniwally]

Nope I can't see how one team would have an advantage if you've played mafia before you'll know that the village can still end up killing other villagers it's all a matter of deception so yeh you should still be able to play. If the mafia end outnumbering the villagers then they win so if it was even teams like I think you're suggesting they'd only need to kill one person to win.

[Mastermind79]

That's great!

So, the players are:
1. Demagog
2. Wardead
3. mafidufa 
4. Kamietsu 
5. xdude 
6. markilleruk
7. killsdazombies 
8. icybraker
9. Belthazar666 -
10. diet soda! 
11. This_is_a_face 
12. miniwally
Sorry, miniwally, that's all the spots. EDIT: nevermind. thanks, scaredgirl.
In a few hours, roles will be sent by PM.
At 8:00 PST, the first storyline post will go out.

[Scaredgirl]

Nope I can't see how one team would have an advantage if you've played mafia before you'll know that the village can still end up killing other villagers it's all a matter of deception so yeh you should still be able to play. If the mafia end outnumbering the villagers then they win so if it was even teams like I think you're suggesting they'd only need to kill one person to win.

From the rules:

This "Day" and "Night" continue until one side is the only one left, and then that side is declared the winner.

And if one side is bigger.. doesn't that mean they have an advantage?

Well, doesn't matter anymore because it looks like I'm playing and you are not

That's great!

So, the players are:
1. Demagog
2. Wardead
3. mafidufa 
4. Kamietsu 
5. xdude 
6. markilleruk
7. killsdazombies 
8. icybraker
9. Belthazar666 -
10. diet soda! 
11. This_is_a_face 
12. miniwally
Sorry, miniwally, that's all the spots. EDIT: nevermind. thanks, scaredgirl.
In a few hours, roles will be sent by PM.
At 8:00 PST, the first storyline post will go out.

[Mastermind79]

Nope I can't see how one team would have an advantage if you've played mafia before you'll know that the village can still end up killing other villagers it's all a matter of deception so yeh you should still be able to play. If the mafia end outnumbering the villagers then they win so if it was even teams like I think you're suggesting they'd only need to kill one person to win.

From the rules:

This "Day" and "Night" continue until one side is the only one left, and then that side is declared the winner.

And if one side is bigger.. doesn't that mean they have an advantage?

Well, doesn't matter anymore because it looks like I'm playing and you are not

That's great!

So, the players are:
1. Demagog
2. Wardead
3. mafidufa 
4. Kamietsu 
5. xdude 
6. markilleruk
7. killsdazombies 
8. icybraker
9. Belthazar666 -
10. diet soda! 
11. This_is_a_face 
12. miniwally
Sorry, miniwally, that's all the spots. EDIT: nevermind. thanks, scaredgirl.
In a few hours, roles will be sent by PM.
At 8:00 PST, the first storyline post will go out.

Yeah, I'm sorry bout that, but those are the rules.

[miniwally]

That;s a shame that you can't ad an extra role can't see why not but it's your game so your decision is final.

[Demagog]

You could just add an extra nurse or detective. Since your rules say they can choose to use their action every two nights, they would just agree when to use their actions, and in the detectives' case, they would agree who to investigate, just like the mafia members agree who they should kill.

And SG, it's actually very balanced. The mafia members are guaranteed at least one kills before they can lose, and the chance of one of them being killed in the early rounds is low because they will vote for the same person to be lynched during the day, and just add their votes to someone else that has a lot of votes. And if one of them is clearly going to be lynched no matter what, the other mafia member votes to lynch them as well so they won't be suspected as the other mafia member. Even if it's five people against one mafia member, the mafia member can still win. I would know, I did it the first time I played :-D I even voted to lynch my partner in crime to throw off suspicion. Two against ten is quite fair (or two against eleven).

[miniwally]

It's annoying if you vote him though and then he rats you up for voting him off but then again he can lie about who's his partner in crime. I'm surprised you're already giving away your tactics demagog

[Demagog]

Well everyone, it seems that Mastermind has started sending out role assignments. I'm assuming I got mine first since I was the first person on the list. Remember, you can claim to be any role. So a mafia member may say they are the detective, or the detective may say they are a civilian/ordinary person. Obviously there are other claims that can be made, those aren't the only ones.

So I'll start by saying: I'm not a mafia member.

[icybraker]

Hey, guys! I have a special position!

I might be a False God. I might be a doctor. I might be a seer. I might be lying. I might be retarded.

[killsdazombies]

Hey, guys! I have a special position!

I might be a False God. I might be a doctor. I might be a seer. I might be lying. I might be retarded.

best line ever?

ok for my line : Its amazing how something can go from bad to total crap*storm

*edited for cursein, sorry