I think any non-lifeshield is inferior (lolol, to think that having bad shields was supposed to be lifes weakness other than complete lack of options for dealing with shields and creatures); towershield only cost 2
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/835b7/835b718338b7c3ed4d950c6cc391d47177a4de41" alt="Underworld :underworld"
less, but loses both reflective and indestructible and ups, although it can be paid with
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/6f20f/6f20fdc5d87bd18a3bdab6114dd6571d926d26ed" alt="Fire :fire"
at least, but i dont think its worth
fireshield similiarly falls short of carapace, which tbf, we dont have in vault. felt unnecessary when we have firestorm.
We may use a 3rd copy of jadeshield in our stalls if we run only 2 stalls.
with a couple of jade staffs in the deck we can justify running more pends, allowing jade to come out earlier.