It basically tries to do a whole lotta everything and ends up doing nothing. At the very least, it should be able to stall an ample amount with granite skins. Silence is to give this deck a head start, or at least offer a bit of protection. Nymph and water are meant to be additional stalling components, although having a permafrost out usually decides whether you win or not. Death is just to give an edge; now it can kill anything w/o healing (unfortunately, everything has sogs nowadays) with a whopping 30 poison from deadly poisons.
I think that this deck has a pretty high chance of decking out any deck without permanent control. If it does have permanent control, ai can get lucky with an enchanted permafrost, and maybe even an enchanted arsenic.
If the fg killer has no intrinsic damage potential (monoaether, liquid antimater, shak'ars revenge) then that deck basically screwed. Stalling or death by poison is definitely possible.
Now, someone has been telling me that rol/hope could totally rush this, but I think that with enough silences, with the permafrost, etc, that it would fall. So maybe rol/hope only has a 60% chance win rate over Iron Maiden.
EDIT: I can't believe I didn't take rush decks into account! Assuming it takes the average vulnerable(no PC) rush deck 8 turns to beat FGs, Iron Maiden will probably have at least 1-3 Granite Skins by turn 7, 21
from mark, and 4-8
from pendulums, so I agree with Essence that rush decks would certainly have an easy time with Iron Maiden, although they do have to deal with some minimal healing..
This is a proposal for one of the FGs, so this is by no way supposed to be harder than obliterator, rainbow, or hermes. Iron Maiden is only supposed to be an fg that will give new players a hard time and old players something fun to kill. Iron Maiden is only supposed to bring something
new to the table.