Guess My Card: A Quickdraw Design Game

[ZephyrPhantom]

1. I come back after a first toss.
2. If you have your hand open, I'm very reusable.
3. My element is Material!

10 minutes as of this post.

[ddevans96]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Chakram | Chakram
4
Weapon: Deals 7 | 8 damage. Returns to your hand after a successful attack.
7 | 5 when flying (8 | 5 upped)

[Treldon]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Only returns to hand if there are at least 2 available slots
Only attacks enemy creatures

[dawn to dusk]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Vengeful Warrior
4 creature (5|1)
if killed, 2 copies are played in your hand with +2 cost

[Zyardran]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Unupped:
Element:
Recycled Sword
Type: permanent
Cost: 5
Decsription: immaterial. Weapon deal 4 damage.
if casted with flying weapon, returns to hand if hand is open.

Upped: same thing except deal 6 damage with a cost of 6.

[AD TienzuStorm]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Boomerang
4 Air
Spell
Deal 10 damage to the opponent and discard a random card. Generate a copy of Boomerang in your hand.

Upped is same except 3 Air

[ZephyrPhantom]

ddevans: Simplest execution of the concept, and despite opposing element, I think this is worth a post. Not 100% on target, though.
Treldon: Multiple hits, huh; seems to be to Owl's Eye as Thunderstorm is to Shockwave. Close, but not quite.
Dawn: Interesting pseudovanilla idea but not what i was looking for, unfortunately.
Discord : Seems inefficient, most people wouldn't want to combo with Flying Weapon. Interesting intent but not very close.
AD: Possible unstable in terms of balance but it gets the spell type, Element, and recursion the closest.

1st) AD
2nd) dd
3rd) Treldon

[AD TienzuStorm]

1. I hate winter, like ew honestly no, ice is bad, it kills me
2. But if I'm with my in element friends, I can thrive and display my element's themes
3. But don't separate us, it makes me shrivel and be small. Ew

So yeah,

10 minutes from posting.

[Zyardran]

Spoiler for Hidden:

[Treldon]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Oh, right: dies if frozen...

[ZephyrPhantom]

Spoiler for Hidden:

Fragile Tree 4 | 3
0 | 1
Dies if frozen.
Omnisynthesis: Gains +1 | +1 each turn if you control an ally  , ,  , or  creature. Otherwise, gains -1  | -1 each turn.

[AD TienzuStorm]

Epic Nature Spirit Thing Fairy
2 Life
2 | 1
Dies if frozen
Set stats to 4 | 4 if another Life creature is in the field and gain the ability Growth

Z was closest so he wins and I'm too lazy to give individual judging reasons.