lost ancients

[shockro]

i'd love to see a while set of new cards that feed off the ideas of the elements, i cant figure out the card creator so i'm just posting here...

  eternal wisp- 5 3/5------- when this creature is destroyed place it in your hand instead

  typhoon-- 7 6/5----- deal 1 damage to all creatures every time it attacks

  shadow 5 3/1----- sacrifice this creature to congeal a target and copy it.

  lasting poison  7:death  (spell)----- add 2 poison to the opponent, return this card to your hand

  cataclysm  7 (spell)---- destroy all pillars on the field

  instability 6 (spell) creature gains unstable (unstable- creature mutates stats every turn, not effects)

  pyroclasm2 2/2------  1 destroy 1 of your pillars, pyroclasm gains 4/4

  ancient defender 9 2/30------ all creatures get -1 health

  sylvian call 6 (spell) ------ place 3 2/2 animal cards into play

  retribution 4 (perm with 2 counters) ----- all cards that deal damage are dealt damage in turn (creatures hit themselves as well as you, spells hit you and the other player

  awakened ancient 3 7/10------- creature comes into play 3 turns after a player plays it

  frostbite 12 (spell) ---- your opponent is frozen for a turn (ice their hp bar)

[guolin]

I like the idea, but some of these cards are off balance. (too OP, too UP)
 
For example, Frostbite is horrible UP. What does freezing the opponent do? I say it should freeze their weapon and lower the cost. Typhoon is OP. Needs a cost increase.

[Revilo]

I really like some of those ideas, but I agree with guolin in that a lot of the cards need balancing.
Typhoon should have it's att/HP lowered dramatically.
Retribution also need changing, it's too strong.

[avidteen13]

Shouldn't this be in the "Card Ideas and Art" section?  You'll probably get more feedback, too.

If frostbite is going to cost that much, it should freeze all of your opponent's creatures.  Pyroclasm shouldn't gain that much; +3/+3 at the most.

[shockro]

by freeze the player i essentially meant skip their turn, but call it freezing them instead. skip sounds too much like uno