Dead threads (ideas made before crucible) are not going to go into the directory, unless we add the smithy. The quality of the idea has no affect on whether or not a card is in the database, since the quality of an idea changes in the eye of the beholder.
By "quality" I mean the fact that the card idea uses the template and has card image. We have some older, great ideas, that are very good, but missing the correct template.
With Smithy cards the idea is naturally to
remake the best ones, and send them to Crucible first. That is
if we want to do that. But before we need to even thing about that, we have about 800 other ideas to take care off.
Where is this Directory going to be located when it is finished?
Who will have to maintain it and keep it up to date?
May I have a link to it?
Sticky topic in the main area, with both the spreadsheet embedded, and a link to a full-screen version.
Getting all those 800+ card ideas submitted, is going to be a big community volunteer project. Maybe we'll use one weekend for it?
Once we have all the current ideas added, the users themselves will have to submit their ideas in the database using the form. Submitted ideas will be proof-read by Card Curators.
Links are in the first post.
Where is this Directory going to be located when it is finished?
Who will have to maintain it and keep it up to date?
May I have a link to it?
I'd assume it'd be in the original thread (http://elementscommunity.org/forum/index.php/topic,19043.0.html), but if SG says otherwise I'm not one to object.
When projects like this one become official, there is no individual "ownership" over the idea anymore. It becomes a community project where everyone chips in. The most logical place is the main area sticky topic, so that is where it will go. And besides, the original idea was only
links to card idea topics. This thing here is much more than that.